The New Testament Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words

The New Testament - Essay Example The motivation behind such a satisfaction is the observer of the supporter being instructed that the person in question ought to be salt and light. The basic reason for witness is heart mentality or joy as prominently known. Eight perspectives of blessedness or four sets are given to the pupil, which will make them be the impact they should be, while getting a charge out of blessedness. Refrain 5 is only one of the eight expressing, â€Å"Blessed are the resigned, for they will acquire the earth.† Jesus or the gospel author detailing Jesus goes legitimately to essential statute of being an impact for greatest effect and review, and afterward assembles the contention in a way which is conspicuous to any Jew of that day, with the end goal of declaration and Christ similarity put resulting to the fundamental statutes of life being clarified. B. Type of this section: The substance and type of this entry is a common of a message by Jesus where he peruses out a content and afterward plunks down, whereby he welcomes them for a more intensive investigate what he has spoken about. As far as the source there is just a solitary clear equal of this section and style, which is in Luke 6 (Though closer investigation demonstrates availability to many composition of the OT). In light of the two source hypothesis, if follower Matthew and Doctor Luke had hotspots for these it would have been ‘Q’ and not Mark. â€Å"The proof focuses to the way that both Matthew and Luke were alluding to a similar entry. â€Å"Luke 6:17 methods a level in a precipitous zone 21 and there are striking likenesses between the two messages, at that point how would we accommodate Matthew's Honored are the poor in soul and Luke's Honored are poor people? Must one be more recorded than the other based on redaction basic standards? Not based on an outreaching utilization of the apparatuses. Matthew is underscoring the profound side and Luke the financial side of a similar unique sayi ng. As it were, both are similarly historical.† (Osborne, 199) C. Structure: While parallelism is a Hebraic idyllic style and The New Testament is written in Greek it must not be overlooked that it is citing Jesus who is from a Hebraic social milieu. Hebraic idyllic parallelism doesn't utilize rhyming words however rhyming thoughts and there is extraordinary legitimacy in observing Matthew 5:3-10 through this viewpoint D. Redaction: While redaction alludes to the writer going about as a manager to suit the first substance to his own goals for composing, it doesn't really imply that the substance is rendered degenerate. On the off chance that this contention is to be founded on the two-source hypothesis, at that point there is the likelihood that Matthew masterminded part 5 to show legitimate progression of the Old Testament in the new verifiable setting to set Jesus over the pharisaic figures and the pharisaic lessons. This is all around expressed by Robert Imperato â€Å" Wh ile Pharisees were guaranteeing that their way of life and lessons were the satisfaction of Jewish life, Matthew’s Gospel was asserting that Jesus was the satisfaction of Jewish life (Imperato, 16) E. Watchwords: From the perspective that Matthew has utilized parallelism, the catchphrases of 5:5 would be â€Å"Meek† and â€Å"Inherit the earth†. The other watchword that should be considered is â€Å"Blessed† in wording the setting of the section just as the refrain being exegeted. These words at that point must be comprehended regarding it’

Dunning’s Eclectic Paradigm Essay

Dunning’s Eclectic Paradigm Professor John Dunning proposed the varied worldview as a system for deciding the degree and example of the worth chain tasks that organizations own abroad. Dunning draws from different hypothetical points of view, including the relative preferred position and the factor extents, monopolistic bit of leeway, and disguise advantage speculations. Let’s utilize a genuine firm to represent the mixed worldview. The Aluminum Corporation of America (Alcoa) has more than 130,000 workers in about 43 nations. The company’s incorporated activities incorporate bauxite mining and aluminum refining. Its items incorporate essential aluminum (which it refines from bauxite), car parts, and sheet aluminum for drink jars and Reynolds Wrapâ ®. The mixed worldview indicates three conditions that decide if an organization will internationalize through FDI: proprietorship explicit favorable circumstances, area explicit focal points, and disguise focal points . To effectively enter and direct business in a remote market, the MNE must have proprietorship explicit favorable circumstances (one of a kind to the firm) comparative with different firms previously working together in the market. These comprise of the information, aptitudes, capacities, procedures, connections, or physical resources held by the firm that permit it to contend successfully in the worldwide commercial center. They add up to the firm’s upper hands. To guarantee universal achievement, the preferences must be considerable enough to counterbalance the costs that the firm acquires in building up and working outside activities. They additionally should be explicit to the MNE that has them and not promptly transferable to different firms. Instances of possession explicit focal points incorporate restrictive innovation, administrative aptitudes, trademarks or brand names, economies of scale, and access to significant monetary assets. The more significant the firm’s possession explicit points of interest, the more probable it is to between nationalize by means of FDI. One of Alcoa’s most significant possession explicit points of interest is the exclusive innovation that it has obtained from R&D exercises. After some time, Alcoa has likewise obtained unique administrative and advertising aptitudes in the creation and promoting of refined aluminum. The firm has a notable brand name in the aluminum business, which helps increment deals. Since it is an enormous firm, Alcoa additionally benefits from economies of scale and the capacity to fund costly undertakings. These favorable circumstances have permitted Alcoa toâ maximize the exhibition of its global activities. Area explicit points of interest allude to the similar focal points that exist in individual remote nations. Every nation has a one of a kind arrangement of focal points from which organizations can determine explicit advantages. Models incorporate normal assets, talented work, minimal effort work, and reasonable capital. Refined administrators perceive and try to profit by the host nation preferences. Aloca-tion-explicit favorable position must be available for FDI to succeed. It must be gainful to the firm to find abroad, that is, to use its possession explicit favorable circumstances related to probably some area explicit points of interest in the objective nation. Something else, the firm would utilize sending out to enter outside markets.17 as far as area explicit points of interest, Alcoa found processing plants in Brazil due to that country’s immense stores of bauxite, a mineral found in moderately hardly any different areas around the world. The Amazon and other significant streams in Brazil create colossal measures of hydroelectric force, a basic fixing in power serious alum inum refining. Alcoa likewise benefits in Brazil from ease, generally knowledgeable workers, who work in the firm’s treatment facilities. Disguise preferences are the points of interest that the firm gets from disguising outside based assembling, appropriation, or different stages in its worth chain. At the point when beneficial, the firm will move its proprietorship explicit focal points across national fringes inside its own association, instead of disseminating them to autonomous, remote substances. The FDI choice relies upon which is the best optionâ€internalization as opposed to using outer partnersâ€whether they are licensees, merchants, or providers. Disguise points of interest include: the capacity to control how the firm’s items are created or showcased, the capacity to control spread of the firm’s restrictive information, and the capacity to lessen purchaser vulnerability about the estimation of items the firm offers. 18 Alcoa has disguised a considerable lot of its tasks as opposed to having them taken care of by outside free providers for five reasons. To start with, Alcoa the executives needs to limit spread of information about its aluminum refining operations†information the firm gained at incredible cost. Second, contrasted with utilizing outside providers, disguise gives the best net come back to Alcoa, permitting it to limit the expenses of tasks. Third, Alcoa needs to control deals of its aluminum items to abstain from discouraging world aluminumâ prices by providing an excess of aluminum into world markets. Fourth, Alcoa needs to have the option to apply a differential evaluating methodology, charging various costs to various clients. The firm couldn't separate its costs successfully without the power over the circulation of its last items that disguise gives. At long last, aluminum refining is a mind boggling business and Alcoa needs to control it to keep up the nature of its item s.

Fresh Ink New Books Out Today January 29, 2013

Fresh Ink New Books Out Today January 29, 2013 Just a few of the tasty new  books available today. Hope youll find something you like. Contents May Have Shifted by Pam Houston (W.W. Norton) Okay, this column is supposed to be all about brand new  books, but theyre my rules and Ill break em if I want to. Pam Houstons memoir-ish novel-in-vignettes was one of my  favorite  books of 2012like, it was one of my top 2 picks for the whole yearand its out in paperback today. Go order a copy now. Ill wait. This is a story about love gone wrong, friendship gone right, and how sometimes we leave home looking for something that it turns out weve had all along. If youve never read Houston, this novel is a great way to discover her signature mixing of fiction with memoir. And the travel passages! Oh man. If you can finish this book without wanting to throw a change of clothes into your backpack and jump on the next flight to anywhere, well, you might be doing it wrong. Highly recommended, especially if you like your fiction a little on the experimental side. Data: A Love Story by Amy Webb (Dutton) If at first you dont succeed, hack the system and try again. Amy Webb has been ubiquitous of lateIve read a TON about this book and her story but havent actually read the book yetwith this memoir about what happened when she applied her professional skills as a digital consultant to her personal life. Rather than chalk her online dating failure up to her impossibly high standards, she decided to figure out why her JDate profile wasnt attracting the right men, then use her new knowledge to build an irresistible profile. So she created another JDate account, this one as a man (and at this part, all of us who have been watching MTVs Catfish, shake our heads in sad recognition), and collected crazy data about the responses her fake man received from women. After she made over her real account with the info she gained from her undercover work, Webb met the man and lived to tell. This story makes me simultaneously more skeptical about online dating and really proud of a smart woman for hacking the system. Im looking forward to reading it soon. Speaking from Among the Bones: A Flavia de Luce Novel by Alan Bradley (Delacorte Press) Everyones  favorite precocious girl detective is back! Alan Bradleys Flavia de Luce novelswhich began with the uber-charming Sweetness at the Bottom of the Piesee their fifth installment with this, billed as his most tantalizing mystery yet. Even if mystery isnt your thing, youre likely to love Flavias voice and her observations about her family and surroundings in rural England. If you havent had the pleasure of meeting her yet, I suggest you stock up on Flavia and devour the set whole on your next snow day. Why We Write: 20 Acclaimed  Authors on How and Why They Do What They Do edited by Meredith Maran (Plume) You dont have to attend too many author events before you figure out that most writers are way more interested in talking about why they write than about where their ideas come from. In this essay collection, 20  authorsfrom David Baldacci to Jennifer Egan to Rick Moody to Ann Patchettdiscuss the art and craft of the  writing life. Editor Meredith Maran covers the bases with writers who represent a variety of genres and levels of literary-ness. The anthology gives readers a personal, slice-of-life look at writers whose work they enjoy, and theres plenty here to inspire aspiring  writers as well. Check out the excerpt of Jennifer Egans piece at Salon for me. Sign up to Unusual Suspects to receive news and recommendations for mystery/thriller readers. Thank you for signing up! Keep an eye on your inbox.

Chapter 2 Research Methodology. 1.Introduction. In This

Chapter 2: Research Methodology 1. INTRODUCTION In this chapter, describes the research method that was followed. It including the research design and participants, and the techniques and data analysis methods that are used for research and detected. Moreover, it is also discussing the techniques used to carry out the experimental work. 2. Research Methods 2.1. Research Design This research is designed to provide a program that helps the user to search and detect the provenance of news articles from different news websites. This research studied the extent of effectiveness of using a technique Google Search API and technique Google Custom Search to detect the provenance of news articles in various news websites. Also, detect the†¦show more content†¦In order to achieve the best and the maximum the correctness, accuracy, credibility and speed of display the results. It is clear from the work breakdown structure (WBS) in Figure 1. The research focused multiple work packages (WP) to develop a system to detect the provenance of news articles, as shown in Figure 2. †¢ WP 1: Literature Review The data are collected through scientific papers and related publications to the provenance in general, and detect the provenance of news articles in particular. †¢ WP 2: Create the architectural design and analysis the system of detected the provenance of news articles 1. Architectural Design This work package focuses on the research and detecting the provenance of news articles that are described and presented in the literature. As well as the work of the design architecture of the system detecting the provenance of news articles. 2. System Analysis 1. Functional requirements 2. Non-functional requirements †¢ WP 3: Prototype or Develop a model to detect the provenance of news articles Through explaining how to use the techniques Google Custom Search and Google Search API to search and detect the provenance of news articles. As well as verification of the proposed architectural design. †¢ WP 4: Validation Experiment the system using two techniques, and selection the technique that has the most efficient and accurate to display the results. ThroughShow MoreRelatedOnline Social Networks1030 Words   |  4 PagesCHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction..............................................................................................................2 1.2 Problem Outline............................................................................................................3 1.3 Objectives.....................................................................................................................3 1.4 Research Methodology..........................................................Read MoreConstruction Industry : Statistics And Policy1344 Words   |  6 PagesChapter 1 introduction The construction industry is a major contributor to the UK and the world in general’s economies as a whole. In 2012 in the UK alone the gross value added was  £83 Billion accounting for 6% of the total economy for the UK according to the paper produced by Chris Rhodes for the House of Commons titled Construction Industry: statistics and policy. (1) Due to the scale of the contribution the construction industry makes to the economy it has been the focus of various reports andRead MoreConcrete And Concrete Of Concrete Materials978 Words   |  4 Pages1.1 Back ground of the research Concrete is known as a construction material which is widely used throughout the entire world. According to the research, concrete contains Portland cement and it is an essential element to concrete (Naik and Moriconi, 2010). This essential element is capable of releasing carbon dioxide significantly. As carbon dioxide is known to be a green house gas, hence it can be said that this type of concrete is damaging the environment. In order to save the environment a newRead MoreImplementation Process And Time Scheduling Process Before Start Construction Phase Essay1536 Words   |  7 PagesABSTRACT With increasing projects size, needing for planning and control become matter of urgency, so this research aim to develop integrate cost estimate process and time scheduling process before start construction phase. Most of construction companies make project scheduling without attention to add planned resources (labor-equipment-material) with its direct and indirect costs to get total project cost. So it is needed to be estimate project direct and indirect cost before start constructionRead MoreDecision Support Tool For Dynamic Job Shop Scheduling785 Words   |  4 PagesSCHEDULING ATIKAH BINTI SELAMAT (FA12015) SUPERVISOR: DR. MUCHAMAD OKTAVIANDARI TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGES CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background 1.2 Problem Statement 1.3 Objectives 1.4 Scope of Research 2 3 3 3 CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Introduction 2.1.1 Job Shop Production 2.1.2 Job Shop Scheduling Problem (JSSP) 2.1.3 Dynamic Job Shop Scheduling Problem (DJJSP) 2.2 Previous Research on Job Shop Scheduling 2.2.1 Job Shop Scheduling 2.2.2 Approach and Method 2.2.3 Performance Measures 2.2Read MoreDeposit Mobilization in Banks1071 Words   |  5 Pages[pic] School of Management [pic] SUMMER INTERNSHIP PROJECT On Deposit Mobilization A Research Project Submitted to Add Value in the Degree of Masters of Business Administration (2009-2011) Faculty Guide Company Guide Name Name Prof.Aditya Verma Mr. Ramesh singh Read MoreEvaluation Methodology For Research Methodology1054 Words   |  5 PagesChapter 3 3.1 Introduction In this chapter, will be focused on the methodology that is use during the research in order to make sure that research can be delivered on time. For this research, the suitable approach for the research methodology would be Research Methodology. This methodology is chosen because it provides the standards for research methods. With this methodology, the research will be done consecutively according to the specifics steps that is planned for every phases. 3.2 MethodologyRead MoreThe Critical Success Factors Of Aldi763 Words   |  4 PagesCritical Success Factors of ALDI focusing on The Buyer Behavior and Involvements Module Dissertation Researcher Kalamba Mbungu Date 08-July-2016 Student Number 21306194 Module Code Module Leader: Dr Alex Pietrus This dissertation is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree in Marketing Practice AcknowledgementsRead MoreThe Implementation of Facilities Management for Disable People at Universiti Teknologi Mara in Malaysia909 Words   |  4 PagesFACILITIES MANAGEMENT FOR DISABLE PERSON IN UITM 1.0 INTRODUCTION Disable persons are special individuals who are considered missing a functional ability compared with a normal society. The movement of people with disabilities is limited and hard to do things without help and proper facilities. The term refers also to the individual such as mental health problems, physical weakness, sensory, cognitive, and intellectual. Individuals with this weakness usually occurs from birth and is also calledRead MoreCloud Ides ( Integrated Development Environments1040 Words   |  5 Pages1 Introduction ============== 1.1 Overview ------------ With the enrollment of the new Computing curriculum to all schools in the UK, teachers have less time - they also have to learn about programming and its principles. Although many resources are available for learning programming [@berry_computing_2013], there have been a lack of resources; knowledge and tools to modify the complex network environment, to set-up a working compilation environment for embedded systems[@harbird_problem_2015].

Problems Facing Physical Education Essays - 468 Words

Problems Facing Physical Education I am not one hundred percent positive, but I am pretty sure I want to major in Physical Education. There are many problems and dilemmas facing professionals in Physical Education. Problems range from poor facilities to kids not receiving proper treatment in the class. I think the biggest problem is the poor facilities. Most states do not even meet the minimum recommendations for physical activity of 50 to 200 minutes a week, according to a 1997 National Association for Sport and Physical Education survey. Even if the kids have a regular physical education class they may not be getting any real exercise. One study in California found that during the course of one week, school kids were getting†¦show more content†¦(According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 14 percent of children ages six to 11 are overweight, as are 12 percent of adolescents.) Its not just from poor eating habits. The average child in America spends more than four hour a day watchin g TV or playing computer or video games. If the children are not getting the proper amount of exercise then that can make the difference between being normal weight and overweight. Too many PE programs are characterized by over sized classes, poor facilities, and little administrative support. Another dilemma facing PE has nothing to do with the budget or facilities. Some teachers teaching the classes are not properly qualified or trained. A lot of programs have instruction-equating punishment with exercise. From what I understood this had to do with things like, allowing students to pick teams, evaluating performance on things such as showing up properly attired rather than learning, and letting the best athletes in the class dominate. I interviewed Larry Becker, one of my high school football coaches and also PE teacher, to see what he thought were the major concerns and dilemmas facing Physical Education. I talked to him about going into Physical Education as my major be cause I want to be a coach. He said probably the biggest misconception is that people go into Physical Education to be a coach or just a PE teacher and they do not really realize that not tooShow MoreRelatedWhat Are The Largest Problems That Plague America? Essay1383 Words   |  6 PagesWhat are the largest problems that plague America? Most would argue that issues such as mass hunger, climate change and poverty are the most prominent difficulties that the United States faces. While these things are important, and do have a great impact on the country, there is another large and often forgotten issue that faces America: childhood obesity. This nationwide problem is also directly harmful to the strength and conditioning industry. Physical education classes are failing to involveRead MoreThe Plight of Canada’s Fitness990 Words   |  4 Pagesprovince in Canada in which physical education credits between grades 9 to grade 12 are required for graduation, the program is facing several issues from the large class size, limited space, and specialist versus generalist teachers issue. Thus, physical education programs needs to be enforced and should be mandatory nationwide. Incontrovertible, physical education programs are getting more attention in the last few years. It is the key to increase teenager’s physical activity levels. MoreoverRead MoreNegative Effects Of Child Labor In Ghana1583 Words   |  7 Pageschild labor is employed. This is one of the famous slogans that shows the severity and the cruelty of child labor. Child labor refers to work that threatens children’s health and safety or deprives their right to education (Herring). Child labor is a serious global issue that the world is facing these days. According to the International Labor Organization (ILO), 215 million children worldwide between the ages of five and seventeen work under conditions that are considered illegal, hazardous, or extremelyRead More The Constraints of Poverty Essay901 Words   |  4 Pagescan cause a cycle of poor mental and physical heath (Dittmann, 2003). Poverty causes many problems for the people facing it up front everyday. Not on ly do they go without many necessities, they also face a tremendous amount of stress all the time. The amount of stress combined with the lack of necessities produces extreme health problems. Poor people have to deal with an unhealthy living environment that creates serious mental and physical health problems. Economic status definitely effectsRead MoreThe Effects Of Obesity On An Individual s Health And Well Being954 Words   |  4 Pageswell-being. Adult obesity as a group, is facing stigmatisation and discrimination, stereotyping and negative attitude in the workplace, retail and even healthcare. Obesity was chosen due to the significant, potential threat to the individual health and how this may be an underlying condition of diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, stroke, joint problems, cancer, but also for the uncontrollable number of people that are facing unhealthy weight. Physical, emotional, social as well as financialRead MoreWhy Do Students Experiencing Homelessness?1205 Words   |  5 Pagesunaware who is positioned to be the current local liaison. To emphasize, there have been amendments that were created to the act during 1990, 1994, and lastly in 2001. (Wilkins, Mullins, Mahan, Canfield, 2016) Recently there have been more obstacles facing this policy. To clarify â€Å"lack of funding at both the state and district levels embodies the most obvious barrier to implementation. Lack of cooperation among liaisons, school-based professionals, service agencies, and family members can have a detrimentalRead MoreMedical Advancement Of A Double Edged Sword950 Words   |  4 Pagesme understand some of the core problems facing the American health system. Of these problems, the one I am most invested in is the lack of health education for school-aged children across the country. With regards to nutrition, sexual health and the concept of general welln ess most Americans have a deficit in knowledge that starts at a young age and negatively affects their physical and mental health throughout life. For millions of Americans this lapse in education coupled with the difficulty toRead MoreObesity As A Risk Factor For Cardiac Health844 Words   |  4 Pages After putting together all my researches, I found that they all had the same results to their surveys and data collections and the same conclusion; obesity is a major problem in American society and it leads to multiple health issues. Data shows that obesity is the cause of chronic disease risk, morbidity, high health care costs and social costs (Nestle Jacobson 2000). After the American society has identify obesity as a risk factor for cardiac health, many federal agencies has come upRead MoreChildhood Obesity And Its Effects1384 Words   |  6 PagesChildhood obesity is on the rise and has seen a dramatic increase over recent years. The percent of children facing obesi ty today is 18% and has doubled over the course of 30 years.1 With 2/3 of the adult population being overweight and obese it is no surprise that children are following the trend. Obesity simply defined is excess body fat from an energy imbalance. Obesity occurs when energy intake is more than energy expended and results in excess body fat. Childhood obesity can be measured withRead MoreChildhood Obesity : The Height Of Its Peak936 Words   |  4 Pagesto prevent them from developing health problems in the future. If a solution is not set into place, then this problem will only get worse and worse each and every year. The first solution I will suggest is that we bring back physical education within schools. The second solution I propose is that we regulate fast-food commercials on any form of media that children are able to see. The first solution that I introduced, which is bringing back physical education within the school system is better the

Rank of Icici Stock Minds Free Essays

string(228) " 65 66 67 68 69 70 CHANCHAL KANSAL SUBHASIS SAHA PUNAM ANNASO BANDAL SONU SINGHAL RAJESH MAHADEV ANDIRAO PARESH ISHVAR BHAI MITHANI SAMRAT THATIKONDA TWARIT S TARPARA PUNE KOLKATA PUNE DELHI PUNE RAJKOT DELHI BANGALORE 1509405\." Sheet1 RANK 1 2 3 4 PARTICIPANT NAME COLLEGE NITIN GAJANAN MALUSARE JANARDAN INSTITUTE GIRISH MAHESHKUMAR SAVLANI K S BUSINESS SCHOOL PRATEEK GOVILA BIT MESRA PUNE UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF KISHAN BHATTAD MANAGEMENT SCIENCES (PUMBA) CITY MUMBAI AHMEDABAD RANCHI PUNE PORTFOLIO 1666999. 9 1666553. 6 1666432. We will write a custom essay sample on Rank of Icici Stock Minds or any similar topic only for you Order Now 5 1662356. 05 TURNOVER 16935103. 38 19998020 19946293. 4 0 % GAIN 11. 13% 5. 67% 9. 36% 0. 00% Basis highest % change in profit compared to the previous day portfolio COMMENTS REMARKS 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 JIGAR B SHAH SHANTI BUSINESS SCHOOL INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SAGAR CHOUDHURY (IIM) ISHAN ONKAR TRIVEDI NIRMA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT ANIL KUMAR YADAV IMS GHAZIABAD RAVINDER REDDY IIT – MADRAS (MGMT DEPT) JAY PRAKASH MEHTA KANDIVALI EDUCATION SOCIETYÂ   INDIAN INSTITIUTE OF PARV DHIMAN MANAGEMENT(IIM) LALA LAJPATRAI INSTITUTE OF DHIRAJ KUNDANMAL SONI MANAGEMENT KALPESH RAJPUT B. K. INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT CHETANA’S INSTITUTE OF ROHAN PRAVIN DHUNDUR MANAGEMENT AND RESEARCH PRIYANKA BHIKHABHAI CHAUDHARY INSTITUTE OF PATEL TECHNOLOGY VISHWAKARMA INSTITUTE OF DINOOP HARIDAS NAIR MANAGEMENT PARLE TILAK VIDYALAYA ASSOCIATION INSTITUTE OF VIJAY DALCHAND SOLANKI MANAGEMENT(PTVAIMS) AHMEDABAD ROHTAK AHMEDABAD DELHI CHENNAI MUMBAI KOLKATA MUMBAI AHMEDABAD MUMBAI GANDHINAGAR PUNE 1633101. 34 1630987. 35 1624240. 56 1607499. 08 1603541. 45 1592069. 45 1587710. 2 1583445. 77 1577859. 05 1571068. 17 1569750 1569228. 22 0877028. 01 19601921. 9 18727524. 25 19529775. 94 13647528. 25 17734802. 6 17597289. 8 13905246. 26 8914119. 7 10081802. 57 880898 18632832. 41 11. 75% Mobile Winner – 14. 03. 13 4. 13% 8. 37% -2. 13% 3. 39% 2. 62% 4. 80% 5. 41% 3. 26% 4. 74% 4. 72% 5. 41% 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 MUMBAI 1568526. 09 1558883. 62 1551591. 65 1551477. 36 1548478. 45 1544469. 5 1542588. 9 1540635. 82 1538577. 6 1536670. 52 1536123. 59 1533144. 14 153180 9. 2 9199916 19665170. 27 19578787. 6 9171863. 97 10972784 16540805. 5 3318021. 6955868. 33 3697253. 9 10295002. 38 18981106. 07 17478175. 1 13408401. 9 5. 97% 2. 78% 2. 33% 3. 31% 1. 95% 2. 96% 3. 11% 3. 28% 4. 15% 2. 62% 1. 97% 1. 98% 2. 12% JAY VITTHALBHAI SANGANI MARVADI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT RAJKOT SOM LALIT INSTITUTE OF KUSHAL AMIT PARIKH AHMEDABAD MANAGEMENT BIJAL BHARATH SELARKA SRM SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT CHENNAI DHAVAL RAJENDRA DESAI MUMBAI EDUCATIONAL TRUST (MET) MUMBAI PARIN MARU MUMBAI KJ SOMAYA KETAN POPATBHAI S K PATEL INSTITUTE OF DHAMELIYA MANAGEMENT GANDHINAGAR RONAK JAYSUKH SODHA N. L. DALMIYA COLLEGE MUMBAI VISHWA VISHWANI SCHOOL OF PREM KUMAR HYDERABAD BUSINESS PRARTHANA CHANDAR UNITED WORLD SCHOOL OF AMIN BUSINESS MUMBAI SYMBIOSIS COLLEGE OF ARTS GEORGE PARAPUZHA JOB COMMERCE PUNE LALSINGH SANGRAMSINGH S. B PATIL INSTITUTE OF RAJPUT PUNE MANAGEMENT SUDEEPTA SARMA IILM INSTITUTE FOR HIGHER BORUAH DELHI EDUCATION (IILM ) INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT DEVELOPMENT AND RESEARCH (IMDR) AGNEL CHARITIES AGNEL SEVA SANGHA’S FR. C. RODRIGUES INST. OF MANAGEMENT. STUDIES RUSTOMEJEE BUSINESS SCHOOL DAYANANDA SAGAR ACEDEMY OF TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT MUMBAI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT RESEARCH GURU NANAK INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES (GNIMS) INDIAN INSTITUTE OF KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT (IIKM) AMITY GLOBAL BUSINESS SCHOOL ACCURATE BUSINESS SCHOOL ATHARVA SCHOOL OF BUSINESS NSTITUTEÂ   OF TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT- INSTITUTE OF FINANCIAL MARKETS (ITM-IFM) RAWAL INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT KIRLOSKAR INSTITUTE OF ADVANCED MANAGEMENT STUDIES CITY COLLEGE INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY PARUL INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT INDIAN INSTITIUT OF MANAGEMENT(IIM) MEENAKSHI SUNDARAJAN SCHOOL OF MGMT JAIPURIA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES H. K. INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, STUDIES RESEARCH, JOGESHWARI CHRIST COLLEGE 30 DIVYA RANI SINGH PUNE 1530024. 8 1504035. 81 1. 22% 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 NIKHITA VINAY RANE BHAUMIK KIRTIKUMAR MEHTA SANTOSH KUMAR ANAND PRAKASH YADAV HARMEET HARBINDER ALAG PRAVEEN GANESAN SASANK BANDARUPALLI MD MOHSIN KHAN SNEHAL SHIVAJI SHINDE MUMBAI MUMBAI BANGALORE MUMBAI MUMBAI CHENNAI HYDERABAD DELHI MUMBAI 1529786. 95 1528691. 21 1526535. 5 1526029. 7 1525450 1523362. 3 1522990. 93 1522771. 22 1522282. 7 1514444. 46 0 948645. 9 1174189. 5 0 19633466. 4 7175048. 23 15763374. 15 11326878. 5 1. 99% 0. 00% 1. 83% 2. 37% 2. 29% 1. 56% 1. 53% 0. 94% 0. 54% 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 SAURAV SHARMA PARVEEN GARG ARPAN KUMAR DAS MADHU SUDAN MC SURENDRA BABU GADWALA DIPAK RASIKBHAI KATHROTIYA SHIVANK GOEL DEVIKA RAJU ASHISH RANA BHAVESH HARISH AGARWAL SASWATA GHOSH RAVIPRAKASH RAMSNEHI PRASAD MILAN A THAKKAR NAVEEN KUMAR BHATNAGAR GOVIND PRATAP SINGH MERTIYA BONY KURIAN PUNNOOSE ANSHUL BANSAL ABHISHEK GOYAL SHAIKH MOHD RAMEEZ MUKHTAR KUSHALAPPA B K JABEZ E DANIEL HARDIC VORA VAISAKH E J MUMBAI DELHI PUNE BANGALORE KANPUR BARODA SHILLONG CHENNAI DELHI MUMBAI BANGALORE 1520505. 07 1517381. 9 1516829. 38 1516420. 05 1516038. 59 1515656. 75 1515339. 65 1515279. 58 1515096. 5 1513370. 8 1513242 1513070. 33 1512952. 06 1512904. 4 1512802. 4 1512655. 28 1512567. 22 1512270 1635277. 67 2360833. 43 3211287. 58 2450275. 45 2141875. 73 17414304. 45 0 2676943. 84 0 13356288. 94 99393 6559817. 75 18790067. 43 0 0 9150470. 72 17570914 0 1. 77% 0. 97% 1. 12% 1. 09% 1. 15% 0. 57% 0. 34% 0. 95% 1. 94% 0. 64% 0. 76% 0. 91% -8. 71% 2. 66% 1. 22% 1. 67% 1. 03% 2. 11% IIPM AHMEDABAD PUNE AMITY GLOBAL BUSINESS SCHOOL INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES DEHRADUN (IMS) JK BUSINESS SCHOOL AMITY GLOBAL BUSINESS SCHOOL IIMB MAHARISHI ARVIND INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE AND MANAGEMENT JSPM’S ABACUS INSTITUTE OF COMPUTER SCIENCE AND MANAGEMENT BNMIT BISHOP HEBER COLLEGE IEIBS AKADEMIA REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT MAHARASHTRA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGIES-SCHOOL OF TELECOM (MIT SOT) GLOBSYN TECHNOLOGIES LTD JAYWANTRAO SAWANT INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT RESEARCH SKYLINE BUSINESS SCHOOL CAMP EDUCATION SOCIETY (INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT) ATMIYA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT INDIAN INSTITUTE OF PLANNING MANAGMENT (IIPM, CHATTARPUR) INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT EXCELLENCE DELHI CHENNAI BANGALORE JAIPUR 58 59 60 61 62 PUNE BANGALORE TRICHY MUMBAI BANGALORE 1512104. 65 1511085 1509935 1509755. 86 1509406. 55 0 0 0 2709639. 3 0 1. 10% 0. 91% 0. 99% 2. 31% 1. 00% 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 CHANCHAL KANSAL SUBHASIS SAHA PUNAM ANNASO BANDAL SONU SINGHAL RAJESH MAHADEV ANDIRAO PARESH ISHVAR BHAI MITHANI SAMRAT THATIKONDA TWARIT S TARPARA PUNE KOLKATA PUNE DELHI PUNE RAJKOT DELHI BANGALORE 1509405. 94 1509016. 5 1508847 1508597. 32 1508523 1507986. 75 1507803. 6 1507612 1000214. 4 0 0 4107663. 24 0 0 2278392. 99 119175 1. 35% 1. 33% 0. 71% 0. 57% 1. 07% 0. 43% 0. 93% 0. 85% Page 1 Sheet1 71 72 73 74 75 76 POOJA BALU VETAL RAJESH KUMAR PARAG M LATHIYA ASHUTOSH SINGH ARJUN M MAYANK SINHA ST. MIRA’S COLLEGE FOR GIRLS SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION MANAGEMENT STUDIES (SCMS) LDRP BENGAL INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS STUDIES(BIBS) ST. JOSEPH’S INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AMITY UNIVERSITY B. P. PODDAR INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND TECHNOLOGY (BPPIMT) CMS BUSINESS SCHOOL INDIRA INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT FUTURE BUSINESS SCHOOL GREAT LAKES INSTITUTE OF MGMT PUNE KOCHI GANDHINAGAR KOLKATA TRICHY GURGAON 1507374. 25 1507298. 7 1507284. 66 1506689. 12 1506507 1506000 632126. 6 811641 4166933. 75 137269. 44 1051965 334500 0. 49% 0. 49% 0. 78% 0. 65% 0. 49% 0. 52% 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 SANJANA SEN RAHUL NICHANAMETTLA PRATHAMESH DHARMIK MANDALE POOJA SETHI SANTHOSH KUMAR S SUDHANSHU KESHAV MOURYA ANURAG GUPTA RAM MILAN KANNUJIA KOLKATA BANGALORE MUMBAI KOLKATA CHENNAI MUMBAI JALANDHAR DELHI KOLKATA PUNE KOLHAPUR AHMEDABAD KOLKATA DELHI PUNE JALANDHAR TRICHY AHMEDABAD VISNAGAR JAIPUR 1505896. 5 1505846. 1505772 1505472. 76 1505448. 66 1505371 1505182. 5 1505154. 7 1504923. 27 1504847 1504450. 94 1504090. 2 1503889. 46 1502875 1502740. 5 1502332 1502277 1502240. 76 1501853. 5 1501507. 86 1501469. 41 1501321 15 01252. 75 1501160 1501127. 4 1501077. 05 1500834. 35 1500709. 1 1500515 0 510517. 1 0 243199 16911647. 35 0 0 0 0 1478127. 6 0 16151721. 7 498939. 5 0 714160 450073. 2 0 17700875. 4 0 448070. 76 1047920. 95 0 51487. 28 418670 1032958. 65 0 0 415179. 6 0 0. 33% 0. 33% 0. 61% 0. 57% 0. 23% 0. 52% 1. 33% 0. 60% 0. 54% 0. 12% 0. 00% 0. 87% 0. 81% 0. 48% 0. 15% 0. 08% 0. 13% 1. 41% 0. 64% 0. 10% 1. 34% 0. 12% 0. 12% 0. 08% -0. 08% 0. 38% 0. 03% 0. 08% 0. 03% SHRI VISHVESARIYA IMS LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY GAUTAM BUDDHA UNIVERSITY INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF SUKANTA SAHA BUSINESS STUDIES (IIBS) SADHU VASVANI INSTITUTE OF BHUMIKA NIRMAL SONI MANAGEMENT (SVIMS) SANJAY GHODAWAT INSTITUTE SOURABH INANI (SEMINAR II) VARSHIT BIPINBHAI DOSHI NRIMB AMINUR RAHAMAN GAZI NSHM BUSINESS SCHOOL(NBS) ASIA PACIFIC INSTITUTE OF RENU YADAV MANAGEMENT NASIRUDDIN FAKRUDDIN DR. D. Y. PATIL INSTITUTE OF SHAIKH ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY APEEJAY INSTITUTE OF ANU THANGRIA MANAGEMENT TECHNICAL CAMPUS MAREDDY INDIAN INSTITIUT OF MARKANDEYULU MANAGEMENT(IIM) INDIAN INSTITIUT OF SIDDHARTH M MANAGEMENT(IIM) NARESH DAHYABHAI VISNAGAR INSTITUTE OF PRAJAPATI MANAGEMENT MEGHA AGARWAL BANASTHALI VIDYAPITH CAMPUS JAY PRAKASH CHAUDHARY OXFORD COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT BANGALORE LOKESH DURGESH GHOSAL ITM DOMBIVLI MUMBAI SRN ADARSH COLLEGE OF ASHISH KUMAR MISHRA BANGALORE MANAGEMENT ASHWINI DEVARAJAM SANKA MUMBAI VIVA COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT AMANDEEP SINGH MAINI DELHI INSTITUTE(IMI) RAJ KUMAR GOYAL INSTITUTE FOR ABHISHEK RAI DELHI TECHNOLOGY (RKGIT) VISHAL JALHOTRA DEHRADUN GRAPHIC ERAÂ   UNIVERSITY MONICA SATISH SHARMA ICL COMMERCE COLLEGE VASHI MUMBAI NANDALAL M SIVADAS AMRITA COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT BANGALORE BABU BANARASI DAS NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY MANAGEMENT VIDYALANKAR INSTITUTE OF SUSHMA VIJAY GHADGE MANAGEMENT LALIT SONI ST. KABIR INSTITUTE MANAGEMENT NITU SINHA MERI INSTITUTE MONICA ALLURI NSB KENGUA ASHUTOSH ICFAI BUSINESS SCHOO L(IBS) DILIP MADHUBHAI CENTRE FOR MANAGEMENT STUDIES PRAJAPATI (CMS) SUJITH S KURUP RAI BUSINESS SCHOOL INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS PIYUSH DILIP KHESE MANAGEMENT RESEARCH (IBMR) TUSHAR GULATI ICFAI BUSINESS SCHOO L(IBS) JAYDEEP PRATAPRAI INDIAN EDUCATION SOCIETY RATHOD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT(IESIMS) INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL OF AVIJIT SAHA BUSINESS JAGANATH SUBRAMANIAN HYDERABAD BUSINESS SCHOOL SOUMYA SUKHMAY NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF CHATTERJEE COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT (NICM) KALPESH KAILASH SHARMA MDI PRIYANT RAMESHBHAI LADANI OXFORD COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT YASH YOGESHBHAI SHAH K S BUSINESS SCHOOL 2 DR. GAUR HARI SINGHANIA INSTITUTE PUSHPINDER SINGH PURI OF MANAGEMENT RESEARCH INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SASIKANTH BAPATLA (IIM) ABHISHEK MADASSERY FEDERAL INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE ASHOK TECHNOLOGY(FISAT) RIZVI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT KARAN KIRTI DOSHI STUDIES R. A. PODAR INSTITUTE OF AKSHIT BAJ MANAGEMENT ACHARYA’S BANGALORE BUSINESS SURI SAI SRIKANTH SCHOOL INDIAN INSTITUTE OF PLANNING AND VIREN PARMAR MANAGEMENT(IIPM) SREE NARAYAN GURUKULAM SHAHANAS PA COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING FABEESH MOHAMED IIPM, KOCHI G SANDEEP GANDHIKOTA BUSINESS SCHOOL DEEPAK HEDDA GARDEN CITY COLLEGE KOLHAPUR INSTITUTE OF VENUGOPAL LALIT DAVDA TECHNOLOGY INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS AND SAISMITA DALAI COMPUTER STUDIES(IBCS ) SOUMITRA KUMAR INDIAN INSTITUTE OF PLANNING MANDAL MANAGEMENT(IIPM) DIPTI DINESH NADKARNI IEIBS AKADEMIA BLESSINA JEBARAJ JEPPIAR ENGINEER COLLEGE SYMBIOSIS INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS STUTI BANSAL MANAGEMENT (SIBM) INDIAN INSTITUTE OF PLANNING P SUNIL KUMAR MANAGEMENT(IIPM) JAYAMUKHI INSTITUTE OF GOUTHAM BIJJALA TECHNOLOGICAL SCIENCES DEBASISH BAJ ITM BUSINESS SCHOOL ORIENTAL INSTITUTE OF ANIRUDH MAHESH SANGHI MANAGEMENT VIVEK AGARWALA LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY VELS INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS DASARATHY GANESAN ADMINISTRATION GANESH R NIT DEEPMALA YADAV 1 06 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 LUCKNOW MUMBAI AHMEDABAD DELHI BANGALORE KOLKATA AHMEDABAD CHENNAI PUNE HYDERABAD MUMBAI KOLKATA HYDERABAD AHMEDABAD DELHI BANGALORE AHMEDABAD KANPUR KOZHIKODE KOCHI MUMBAI JAIPUR BANGALORE PUNE KOCHI KOCHI HYDERABAD BANGALORE KOLHAPUR BHUBANESHWAR BHUBANESHWAR MUMBAI CHENNAI PUNE HYDERABAD WARANGAL WARANGAL MUMBAI JALANDHAR CHENNAI TRICHY 1500416. 1500306. 63 1500152. 85 1500148 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 Page 2 0 4957494. 14 461163. 8 1164534 0. 04% 0. 75% 0. 01% 0. 59% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 0 0% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% Sheet1 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 PREEYAM HIMANSHU TOLIA GOURAV TYAGI INDRAJEET SARKAR MEVISH PANCHAL PIYUSH MANOJ MODHSARAF CHANDNI JITENDRABHAI ZAVERI ABHYUDAY SINGH CHAUHAN FAIZAN KHAN KARTHIK HARIHARAN PRADEEP V SATENDER SINGH RAWAT PRAMOD AGRAWAL HARSH RANJAN ANIRBAN TARUN HAZRA KUNWAR VIKRAM SINGH BHAVIK JAGDISHBHAI BHAVSAR RAHUL VIJAYAKUMAR PRATIK MAHENDRA MANANI BHAGYASHREE SURESH PATIL SAINATH NIVLAKAR VISHAL SINGH JOHNSON BANDI ANKIT ANAND SHUBHAM JAIN ANUBHAV SINGH PADALIYA DHAVAL DEEPCHAND RADHYASHYAM GUPTA AMRITA MAZUMDAR YOGESH HARSHADBHAI PATEL SUJIT P ANUTOSH KUMAR AJEET PRATAP KHANDE NIKET CHANDAK SATYAJIT MAHAPATRO MANJUNATH RA SHREY ARORA GAURAV KAMBLE JOYDEEP DEY PANKAJ RAMESH RAI SURAJ SANJAY TAMHANE RADHE NARAYANDAS RATHI PRANAY VIJETA MUKESHKUMAR GUPTA KISHANKUMAR CHAUDHARY RAJEN DER AGGARWAL SAMBHAV GUPTA RAJIV TARASHANKAR MAURYA PATHIK ASHOK DOSHI SACHIN DADABHAU ARGADE NIKUNJKUMAR BIPINCHANDRA GOR ARVIND SINGH NABA KUMAR MEDHI AFSAR TANWEER VIVA COLLEGE OF ARTS,COMMERCE AND SCIENCE ITS GHAZIABAD INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT BHARTIVIDYAPEETH COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT ALKESH DINESH MODI IMS MUMBAI GHAZIABAD KOLKATA MUMBAI MUMBAI 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1500000 1499980. 58 1499898. 8 1499840. 31 1499298. 49 1499240 1498978. 6 1498975. 44 1498765. 1 1498463. 91 1498376. 77 1497879. 7 1497736 1497537. 85 1497026. 1 1496824. 5 1496650 1496525. 13 1496018. 95 1495073. 73 1493679. 6 1491854. 05 1490459 1489680 1487377. 61 1485605. 25 1484849 1483542. 5 1481977. 63 1480659. 65 1480337. 56 1480059. 8 1478627. 88 1478035. 91 1477020. 08 1476154. 24 1475551. 17 1474566. 66 1458569. 63 1455800 1450658. 24 1444595 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00% 0. 00 % 0. 48% -0. 01% 0. 13% -0. 05% 1. 24% 0. 00% 0. 18% 0. 08% -0. 11% 0. 54% 0. 54% 0. 68% 0. 00% 0. 50% -0. 23% 0. 73% -0. 27% 0. 16% 0. 7% -0. 04% -0. 35% 0. 13% 0. 88% -0. 38% 0. 14% 0. 12% 0. 77% -2. 62% -1. 70% 0. 95% 0. 69% 0. 23% 2. 83% -0. 67% -4. 74% -0. 41% 1. 31% -2. 50% -3. 29% -3. 72% RAJKOT R K UNIVERSITY DHARMSINGH DESAI INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY MANAGEMENT(DDIT) NADIAD NARSEEMONJI INSTITUTE OF MUMBAI MANAGEMENT STUDIES (NMIMS) INDIAN INSTITIUT OF INDORE MANAGEMENT(IIM ) VELLORE INSTITUTE OF CHENNAI MANAGEMENT (VIT) GLA UNIVERSITY II MATHURA GLA UNIVERSITY I MATHURA JAIPUR GYANVIHAR INSTITUTE DY PATIL INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT MUMBAI BELAPUR SWAMI VIVEKANAND INSTITUTE OF MUMBAI MANAGEMENT STUDIES CHIMANBHAI INSTITUTE OF AHMEDABAD MANAGEMENT CRESENT BUSINESS SCHOOL (B. S. ABDUR RAHMAN UNIVERSITY) CHENNAI ICFAI BUSINESS SCHOOL SANJAY GHODAWAT INSTITUTE ENTREPRENEURSHIP DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE OF INDIA (EDI) JAIPURIA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY(NIT) SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT, KIIT UNIVERSITY INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL OF INFOMATICS MANAGEMENT (IIIM ) TRINITY INSTITUTE OF PROFESSIONAL STUDIES NEW DELHI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT (NDIM) GAHLOT INSTITUTE HERITAGE GROUP OF INSTITUTIONS GANPAT UNIVERSITY XAVIER INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT BIFM SOCIETY FOR EDUCATION RESEARCH LYYOD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT INDIRA COLLEGE FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES (FMS) MS RAMAIAH COLLEGE INSTITUTE OF RURAL MANAGEMENT(IRM) ADITYA COLLEGE NSHM BUSINESS SCHOOL(NBS) UNITED BUSINESS SCHOOL SIES COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT, NERUL D Y PATIL GREATER NOIDA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY GNVS INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT S V INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT(IIM) LUCKNOW AMITY BUSINESS SCHOOL DR. G D POL FOUNDATION YMT COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT FLAME BUSINESS SCHOOL MUMBAI KOLHAPUR AHMEDABAD JAIPUR WARANGAL BHUBANESHWAR JAIPUR DELHI DELHI MUMBAI KOLKATA AHMEDABAD BHUBANESHWAR DELHI DELHI PUNE DELHI BANGALORE JAIPUR MUMBAI DURGAPUR AHMEDABAD MUMBAI PUNE DELHI MUMBAI KADI DELHI AHMEDABAD MUMBAI PUNE 140773. 02 0 469778. 52 5920537. 72 278734. 9 1516500 0 1806549. 85 603598. 3 3727765. 43 9780 0 1359144. 05 0 427764 0 4693020. 75 4546906. 55 293725 148376. 1 2361056. 9 0 0 6257722. 15 0 0 664855. 8 24198 15104297. 55 14073842. 49 6103274. 4 10377288. 23 14504753. 51 7697288. 85 1796680. 35 19766905. 12 1469829. 15 6301258. 4 0 1486542. 2 15548000 MODERN COLLEGE PUNE NARSEEMONJI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES HYDERABAD LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY JALANDHAR INDIAN INSTITUTE OF FOREIGN TRADE KOLKATA – IIFT XISS- XAVIER INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL SCIENCE RANCHI SMT. HIRABEN NANAVATI INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT RESEARCH FOR WOMEN AMRITA SCHOOL OF BUSINESS SANKLP BZ COLLEGE INDIAN INSTITIUT OF MANAGEMENT(IIM) JAGANNATH INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES (JIMS) VIVA COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT JAMNALAL BAJAJ INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES RAJAGIRI SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT ST FRANCIS INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT MODERN INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT JAIPUR ENGINEERING COLLEGE RESEARCH CENTRE (JECRC) SYDENHAM INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 NEHA ANIL SONAWANE ASHIS KUMAR NAYAK ANKUR HANUMANDASJI LOYA RAMAKRISHNA REDDY PV ASHISH VATS NILESH KALOJI PATIL CHAITANYA GANDHI ASHISH M THOMAS SAVIO IGNATIUS PEREIRA PUNE COIMBATORE PUNE BANGALORE DELHI MUMBAI MUMBAI KOCHI MUMBAI 1443019. 28 1438403. 49 1421968. 3 1403592. 6 1387933. 23 1382846. 1 1347535. 19 1315017. 23 1232887. 18 7221815. 06 6706791. 4 7983803. 6 15200000 17918166. 91 15326224 18887715. 9 14959391. 89 18177223. 5 -3. 67% -3. 27% -1. 88% -3. 44% -9. 27% -11. 30% -13. 48% - 13. 75% -12. 7% Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 14-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 14-Mar2013 Disqualified NEHAL MEHUL DOSHI PUNE 2158899. 67 681523032. 99 30. 27% Disqualified INDU RAJ SHARMA JAIPUR 1746172. 62 136730223. 38 3. 01% Disqualified PARIN JAYESH JAIN MUMBAI 1689359. 21 29836586. 33 5. 38% Disqualified MRINAL AGRAWAL ICFAI BUSINESS SCHOOL GURGAON 1652256. 13 1019418. 73 9. 76% Disqualified DIPEN GIRISHBHAI DESAI SJPIM AHMEDABAD 1638720. 53 38609002. 49 5. 92% Disqualified KRATIKA KAPOOR BANASTHALI VIDYAPITH CAMPUS BANASTHALI 1602585. 74 174113219. 86 4. 03% Disqualified AKASH SINGHAL IILM DELHI DELHI 1595289. 76 Page 3 20201491. 1 0. 81% Sheet1 LAL BAHADUR SHASTR I INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT DELHI Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 14-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 rore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 14-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified as Turnover exceeded 2 crore on 13-Mar2013 Disqualified SURBHI BEGWANI 1579115. 33 20629835. 15 2. 46% Disqualified HIMANSHU SHEKHAR BIT MESRA KOLKATA 1548771. 65 85329123. 21 -3. 35% Disqualified SANDEEP KUMAR INDIAN INSTITUTE OF FOREIGN TRADE DELHI (IIFT) 1513222. 8 44599450. 3 8. 38% Disqualified RAHUL SHYAMKUMAR JAIN ICFAI BUSINESS SCHOOL PUNE 1508190. 05 61504026. 95 -6. 39% Disqualifi ed ARUN K IIT – MADRAS ENGG. DEPT CHENNAI 1501859. 94 57156690. 7 -2. 77% Disqualified DEEPANKAR KSHITIZ EMPI BUSINESS SCHOOL NALANDA INSTITUTE OF ADVANCED STUDIES DELHI 1497135. 03 69303860. 97 -2. 90% Disqualified SHEIKH HOSSAIN KOLKATA 1477135. 35 24163113. 25 -1. 52% Disqualified KUNTAL DEVESH DAVE SAL INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AHMEDABAD 1447490 29854052. 5 -6. 76% Disqualified GOBIN RANA SONA COLLEGE OF MANAGMENT INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT TECHNOLOGY(IMT) SALEM 1444626. 85 37832292. 25 -1. 46% Disqualified TUSHAR SHARMA MANMOHAN SINGH SIKARWAR GHAZIABAD 1380792. 05 40439282. 21 -3. 78% Disqualified ICFAI BUSINESS SCHOO L(IBS) AHMEDABAD 1064207. 96 111815542. 74 -21. 15% Page 4 How to cite Rank of Icici Stock Minds, Essay examples

Intervention Course Outline Essays - Psychometrics,

Intervention Course Outline Intervention Course outline: Chapter 1. The Disease of Chemical Dependency Test What we know about the Disease.Test How to Tell if someone you know is Chemically Dependent. Test Chapter One Test 10% of course Chapter 2. The Emotional Syndrome of Chemical Dependency.Test What we know about the Emotional SyndromeTest How Chemical Dependency Affects you.Test Chapter Two Test 10% of course Chapter 3. The Delusional System of Chemical Dependency..Test What we know about the Delusional System.Test How you become part of the Delusional System...Test Chapter Three Test 10% of course Chapter 4. Preparing for the Intervention.Test Conquering your own ReluctanceTest Gathering the Intervention TeamTest Gathering the Data...Test Rehearsing the InterventionTest Finalizing the detailsTest Should you seek Professional Help..Test Chapter Four Test 20% of course Chapter 5. Doing the InterventionTest An Intervention ScenarioTest What if the Intervention doesn't work..Test Getting help for yourself.Test Chapter Five Test 20% of course 500 word essay, with Introduction 20 % of course Completion of 2 mock interventions supervised 10% of course Psychology Essays

Fiscal Policy SA- Budget Speech

Fiscal Policy SA- Budget Speech Table of Contentsi. Executive Summary31. Introduction62. Essence of Budget 200772.1 Total Spending (Medium Term Expenditure Framework Period)83. Economic Backdrop - Buoyant Domestic Growth95. Rationale of 2007 Budget Speech116. Macroeconomy137. Fiscal Policy147.1 Expansionary Fiscal Policy147.2 Tax168. Fiscal and Monetary challenges208.1 Monetary Challenges229. Shortcomings of 2007 Budget.2310. Suggestions on how to address the shortcomings2410.1 Fiscal measures2410.2 Monetary measures2411. List of References:2612.ANNEXURES28i. Executive SummaryWhile delivering the 2007 Budget Speech on 21 February 2007, the elated and charismatic Trevor Manuel's tone typified South Africa's economy that has been performing remarkably well over the past 4 years largely due to sound fiscal and monetary policies and global influences. The increased quantity and quality of spending in the Budget is fuelled by the rationale of summarily accelerating the investment rate and pace of growth; improving the l ives of marginalised South Africans; maintaining a progressive security net; combating crime and improving the capacity and effectiveness of state; show case the country through preparing for the 2010 soccer event; and encouraging the culture of saving.GDPThe Budget and its continued expansionary fiscal stance is however characterised by significant challenges that may impede on progress in achieving certain objectives. These include vis- -vis policy lags, lack of capacity with regard to spending, government red-tape and inefficiencies, adverse rent-seeking behaviour, income and wealth redistribution. Global influences that will pose challenges include the anticipated lower global growth due to suppressed US growth, risks e.g. oil prices; US current account deficit amidst large surpluses amongst oil-producing countries. The main monetary challenge is that the South African Reserve Bank seeks to suppress demand to match supply but this is the low growth option. The proposed long term solution and high growth option is to boost supply in order to meet demand with official and private sector initiatives.A number of items were missing...

10 teléfonos para resolver dudas migratorias en EE.UU.

10 telà ©fonos para resolver dudas migratorias en EE.UU. En Estados Unidos es una necesidad saber dà ³nde buscar informacià ³n migratoria, verificar el estatus de un caso o encontrar asesorà ­a legal reputada y a un costo asequible. Para ello en  este artà ­culo se indican los telà ©fonos y las pginas web especà ­ficas en las que encontrar la respuesta a las dudas migratorias que puedan plantearse. Telà ©fonos clave para informacià ³n migratoria USCIS: 1-800-375-5283EOIR: para detenidos o asuntos en Corte: 1-800-898-7180Denunciar fraudes migratorios: 1-866-347-2423Buscar abogados: base de datos de AILAReferencias de abogados: Hispanic Federation: 1-866-432-9832 Dà ³nde rastrear informacià ³n con el USCIS El Servicio de Inmigracià ³n y Ciudadanà ­a de los Estados Unidos (USCIS, por sus siglas en inglà ©s) brinda varias posibilidades para obtener informacià ³n sobre asuntos que est tramitando o sobre cuestiones que son de su competencia. Entre ellos destacan: Telà ©fono gratuito para solicitar informacià ³n sobre un caso:  1-800-375-5283Servicio INFOPASS online para cerrar una cita para solicitar informacià ³n Adems, antes de acudir a una cita a una oficina de USCIS es posible utilizar su localizador de ubicaciones de oficinas o de sus Centros de Apoyo a Aplicaciones, donde se toman huellas digitales y otros datos biomà ©tricos a los solicitantes de beneficios migratorios. Adems, si ya se ha presentado la documentacià ³n para una peticià ³n o solicitud, es posible verificar online el estatus de un caso, aunque para ello es requisito indispensable conocer el nà ºmero de recibo del mismo. Asimismo, tambià ©n es posible informarse online de cunto se estn demorando en la tramitacià ³n casos similares. Por ejemplo, si se ha presentado una peticià ³n de familiar, es posible rastrear cunto tarda de media esa gestià ³n en todas las oficinas de USCIS. Informacià ³n sobre requisitos para presentar una solicitud ante USCIS En la pgina oficial de USCIS se puede encontrar informacià ³n sobre trmites como por ejemplo solicitar residencia permanente, naturalizacià ³n, permiso de trabajo, ajuste de estatus, perdones, tambià ©n conocidos como waivers o permisos, etc. Asimismo, esa pgina es el lugar en el que se puede acceder a todos los formularios oficiales para presentar solicitudes al USCIS y descargarlos gratuitamente.  Es conveniente utilizar la versià ³n ms reciente del documento que se necesite ya que USCIS los modifica y actualiza perià ³dicamente y no admite las versiones viejas. Centro Nacional de Visas (NVC, por sus siglas en inglà ©s) En el NVC se tramitan gestiones relacionadas con las peticiones de la tarjeta de residencia permanente cuando à ©stas siguen lo que se conoce como un procedimiento consular. En otras palabras, cuando la fase final se realiza fuera de Estados Unidos y es necesario acudir a una embajada o consulado para ser entrevistado y recibir la visa de inmigrante. Como regla general, el NVC es quien contacta. Pero si surge la necesidad de comunicarse con ellos, tambià ©n es posible. Si bien antes de hacerlo es recomendable verificar el boletà ­n de visas para fechas de procesamiento de green card con cupos mximos anuales, como son las peticiones de ciudadanos para hijos casados o mayores de 21 aà ±os de edad o para hermanos o las peticiones de residentes para cà ³nyuges e hijos solteros. Si se ha pedido una visa de inmigrante en casos en los que hay dichos cupos mximos anuales es imprescindible esperar a que la fecha de prioridad del caso sea ms antigua que la fecha de corte publicada en el boletà ­n de visas. Si no ha llegado la fecha de prioridad para la tramitacià ³n de la visa de inmigrante no se avanza absolutamente nada contactando con el NVC. Informacià ³n relacionada con aduanas Para los extranjeros autorizados a permanecer sà ³lo temporalmente en los Estados Unidos es importante para verificar el I-94, registro de entrada y salida, ya que ese documento muestra fecha mxima de estancia con visa de turista. Tambià ©n sirve esa pgina para obtener el rà ©cord de ingresos y salidas del paà ­s. En la actualidad, el I-94 est digitalizado y en la pgina de oficial de ICE para este registro es posible no solo verificar los datos sino tambià ©n imprimir el rà ©cord. Por otro lado, las personas que siempre tienen problemas cuando llegan a un punto migratorio de los Estados Unidos y son enviados a una segunda inspeccià ³n siempre o frecuentemente puede ser conveniente dirigirse al programa que se conoce en inglà ©s como Traveler Redress Inquire Program, para intentar encontrar una solucià ³n. Ciudadanà ­a de los Estados Unidos Para los ciudadanos de los Estados Unidos es importante conocer las opciones de cà ³mo y dà ³nde pueden solicitar el pasaporte. Para este trmite u otros puede necesitarse copia del certificado de nacimiento, cambio de nombre, matrimonio, pedir una nueva copia de la tarjeta del Nà ºmero del Seguro Social, etc. Para ello hay que dirigirse a la oficina de rà ©cords vitales del lugar donde se ha producido el hecho. Arrestos y detenciones Si se sospecha que un familiar o un amigo puede estar detenido, existe una base de datos para saber si est detenido por la Migra. Si no aparece en una centro de detencià ³n migratorio, hay varias formas de enterarse si se encuentra en una  en prisià ³n federal no migratoria o en una estatal. Informacià ³n sobre un caso en Corte migratoria Se puede marcar al EOIR, es decir, la Oficina de revisià ³n migratoria. Los telà ©fonos son  240-314-1500  o  1-800-898-7180, este à ºltimo es gratuito. Si se desea se puede elegir la opcià ³n de espaà ±ol. Por otro lado, para los migrantes es importante enterarse anà ³nimamente si existe una orden de deportacià ³n  y es posible hacerlo. Este punto conviene destacarlo ya que es totalmente posible que un juez haya declarado la deportacià ³n en ausencia y que el migrante no recibiera la notificacià ³n. En estos casos si por cualquier razà ³n se es detenido, la deportacià ³n proceder automticamente, sin pasar por corte. Dà ³nde reportar fraudes migratorios o felonà ­as Al igual que sucede en muchos otros paà ­ses, en Estados Unidos se puede marcar al 911 para reportar cualquier tipo de delitos o solicitar ayuda. Es el telà ©fono de situaciones de emergencia en todo el territorio nacional. En el caso de violencia domà ©stica se puede, adems, acudir directamente a la là ­nea gratuita que lucha contra esta lacra social. Para ello marcar al  1-800-799-7233. Otra opcià ³n es contactar con la Red Nacional contra el Asalto Sexual, Violacià ³n, Abuso e Incesto, que se conoce como RAINN por sus siglas en inglà ©s. En este caso marcar al  1-800-656-4673. Por otra parte, los migrantes son, lamentablemente, và ­ctimas de fraudes ya que siempre hay personas inescrupulosas que aseguran tener contactos o poder lograr resultados positivos en gestiones migratorias cuando no es verdad. Para estos casos es posible denunciar marcando al 1-877-382-4357. Adems, las actividades delictivas o fraudes relacionados con inmigracià ³n o con aduanas pueden reportarse anà ³nimamente al ICE marcando al 1-866-347-2423, incluidos los casos de matrimonios de conveniencia, es decir, los que se celebran para que uno de los cà ³nyuges obtengan los papeles. Dà ³nde solicitar ayuda o asesorà ­a migratoria No cabe duda de que Estados Unidos es un paà ­s que brinda buenas oportunidades. Pero no es menos cierto que se puede sufrir mucha soledad. Para los casos extremos donde se llega a tener pensamientos suicidas, por favor marcar gratuitamente al  1-888-628-9454, donde se habla en espaà ±ol. Otro de los grandes problemas que afectan a los migrantes es la necesidad de obtener buena informacià ³n sobre leyes migratorias y a un costo no elevado. La base de datos de AILA lista por localidad los abogados de su asociacià ³n especializados en migracià ³n. Adems, la Hispanic Federation puede ayudar con algunos trmites como por ejemplo peticiones de familia, DACA, permisos de trabajo, etc y tambià ©n puede brindar referencias a organizaciones con buena reputacià ³n. Marcar al 1-  866-432-9832. Finalmente, en el caso de mexicanos, siempre se puede marcar al telà ©fono de CIAM que es el y que brinda excelentes servicios gratuitamente. En el caso de los hondureà ±os en EE.UU. existen varios telà ©fonos a los que pueden marcar. Por su relevancia se seà ±alan tres en la zona fronteriza: McAllen, Texas: 214-347-4441Houston, Texas: 713-987-7406Los Angeles, California: 323-283-8623 Este es un artà ­culo informativo. No es asesorà ­a legal.

Women's Rights in Islam Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words

Women's Rights in Islam - Research Paper Example Social responsibility among Muslims originated from the Qur’anic scripture which says: â€Å"And [as for] the believers, both men and women—they are friends and protectors of one another: they [all] enjoin the doing of what is right and forbid the doing of what is wrong, and are constant in prayer, and render the purifying dues, and pay heed unto God and His apostle. It is they upon whom God will bestow His grace: verily, God is almighty, wise.†i The above Qur’anic verse indicates that men and women are to cooperate with one another in the educational and political sphere (they should understand God’s commandments and have an influence in society to actualize God’s wisdom), in the social sphere (helping the poor and the disadvantaged), and in the religious sphere (prayer). These required tasks mentioned in the verse reveal that both men and women are to actively take part in society instead of simply being submissive or indifferent. Participation in the political realm is a way to accomplish one’s duties to society. Political participation can be carried out in various ways, from voting, to occupying a position as a magistrate or lawmaker, to being a national leader. Islam offers examples for each of these positions, roles, and duties for women. Within the spiritual realm, Islam does not distinguish between men and women. According to the Qur’an, men and women have to fulfill the same objective—both will receive rewards or punishments based on their personal deeds, both will be tried by God, and both have an obligation to live up to their religious duties. Every time the Qur’an specifies those blessed people who will be accepted to the Garden of Bliss due to their goodness, piousness, and virtue, it cites both men and women: â€Å"And whoever does righteous good deeds, male or female, and is a (true) believer [in the Oneness of Allah (Muslim)], such will enter Paradise and not the least injustice, even to the size of a Naqira (speck on the back of

Business Proposal-ECONOMICS Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1

Business Proposal-ECONOMICS - Essay Example As there are high number of sellers and producers our product will have an edge over the other products as we have the latest technology for the making of leather shoes. Technology has helped us lower the cost by reducing labor cost. As it is homogenous product, it will be sold at a price determined by the market but our quality at that price will be the best as compared to our competitors (Boyes, 2013). The selected product is elastic as change in the price of the product will also change the demand of the product. An increase in price can cause a fall in the demand of the product and by such market response we know that the market is competitive and there can be a difficulty in making more profit. As there is a difficulty in increasing profit, we will introduce our product at a lower cost while maintaining a high quality in the market (McEacher, 2013). The price of my product with the provided quality will be low as compared in the competitive market, so if there will be an overall increase in the prices of shoes it will not affect the demand of my product as compared to those of my competitors in the market and the demand of my product will be less elastic. If the price of overall footwear decreases, the demand of our product will be elastic as we will also lower our prices because our variable cost is low due to less labor cost. Pricing will have an impact on our business because if the price of footwear falls we will earn less profit than we are earning at the current market price. The theories of economics explain that a firm should keep on producing a product until its marginal cost becomes equal to its marginal revenue because it is the point where the profit is maximized. Quantity supplied will keep on increasing until we are earning the more revenue than cost from an additional unit. As discussed above our prices will be low in the market therefore we can produce more to earn more revenue

Movie Essays - Oedipal Hamlet in Film -- Movie Film comparison compare

Oedipal Hamlet on Film      Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚   It has commonly been suggested by such disciples of Sigmund Freud as Ernest Jones that Shakespeare's character of Hamlet is the victim of an Oedipus complex. While any reading of the play Hamlet, Prince of Denmark that focuses on the text and not the psychoanalytical fads of the current age disproves any notion of Hamlet's oedipal nature, many film artists have followed popular psychology and have adopted this theory for the screen. Whether out of precedent, pressure, or some need to discover some complex in Hamlet, this has become a very popular trend for filmmakers. Seeing as how it is impossible to do a production of Hamlet without addressing Hamlet's relationship with Gertrude, Hamlet, Sr., and Claudius, the following will be a discussion of several filmic Hamlets, and the presence, or absence of these Freudian notions. While certainly not the first production of Hamlet for the big screen, Laurence Olivier's 1948 adaptation is the first full length commercial version, and is still highly regarded today. In this film Gertrude looks at Hamlet more like a lover than a mother, gazing at him lustfully whenever he is present. Gertrude's affection is not limited to these gazes, however, as upon Hamlet's agreement to remain at Elsinore she kisses him deep and long on the lips, like a lover. Olivier's Hamlet is initially aggressive toward Gertrude during the closet scene, but after the visit from the ghost he becomes as affectionate as Gertrude is in the beginning. Hamlet speaks to Gertrude tenderly, and she responds accordingly. He then gives her a deep long kiss to seal their pact against Claudius. Taken out of context the scene would appear to be a conversation and love-pact between two ... ...ed complexes and have given us Hamlets free of supposed incestuous wishes and confused notions. This reverence for the script and lack of supposition give the viewer a more accurate view of Hamlet that is more in keeping with the complex mind Shakespeare offered his audience.    Works Cited and Consulted Branagh, Kenneth. "Hamlet" by William Shakespeare: Sreenplay, Introduction, and Film Diary. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1996. Guerin, Wilfred L., Earle Labor, Lee Morgan, Jeanne C. Reeseman, and John R. Willingham. A Handbook of Critical Approaches to Literature. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992. Leong, Virginia. "Hamlet Article from The Australian." 06 December 1997. (07 December 1997) Shakespeare, William. Hamlet, Prince of Denmark. The Riverside Shakespeare. ED. G. Blakemore Evans. Boston: Haughton Mifflin Company, 1974.

Reardon v. U.S. Essay

Lien on real property created by CERCLA when Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) determines that property owners may be liable for cleanup costs amounts to deprivation of a significant property interest within meaning of the due process clause. Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980,  § 107(l ), as amended, 42 U.S.C.A.  § 9607(l ); U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 5. Absence of notice and hearing may be justified by exigent circumstances. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 5. 92k251.5 k. Procedural Due Process in General. Most Cited Cases Constitution allows the process due to be tailored to fit realities of the situation. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 5. *1510 Lynn Wright, with whom Robin F. Price and Edwards and Angell, New York City, were on supplemental brief, for plaintiffs, appellants. George W. Van Cleve, Deputy Asst. Atty. Gen., with whom Barry Hartman, Asst. Atty. Gen., Washington, D.C., Wayne A. Budd, U.S. Atty., George B. Henderson, II, Asst. U.S. Atty., Boston, Mass., Stephen L. Samuels, Steve C. Gold, Jacques B. Gelin, Attys., Dept. of Justice, Charles Openschowski, Office of Gen. Counsel, E.P.A. and Luis Rodriguez, Asst. Regional Counsel, E.P.A., Washington, D.C., were on supplemental brief, for defendants, appellees. OPINION EN BANC TORRUELLA, Circuit Judge. After removing hazardous substances from property belonging to the Reardons, EPA filed a notice of lien on the property for the amount spent. See 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(l ). The Reardons sued to have the notice of lien removed, arguing that they were not liable for the cleanup costs, that the lien was  overextensive in that it covered parcels not involved in the clean-up, and that the filing of the lien notice without a hearing deprived them of property without due process. The district court, in Reardon v. United States, 731 F.Supp. 558 (D.Mass.1990), decided that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the Reardons’ two statutory claims. It ruled that although jurisdiction existed to hear the constitutional claim, the filing of a lien did not amount to a taking of a significant property interest protected by the due process clause. It therefore denied the Reardons’ motion for a preliminary injunction, and dismissed their complaint. The Reardons appealed and a panel of this court ruled in their favor on statutory grounds. Reardon v. United States, 922 F.2d 28 (1st Cir.1990) (withdrawn). We now consider the appeal en banc. After closely considering applicable law, including most notably the recent case of Connecticut v. Doehr, 501 U.S. 1, 111 S.Ct. 2105, 115 L.Ed.2d 1 (1991), we conclude that the district court correctly decided that it did not have jurisdiction to consider the Reardons’ statutory claims, but we find that the CERCLA lien provisions do violate the fifth amendment due process clause. I. BACKGROUND A. Facts. In 1979, Paul and John Reardon purchased a 16-acre parcel in Norwood, Massachusetts, adjacent to an electric equipment manufacturing plant site *1511 known as the â€Å"Grant Gear† site, and named it â€Å"Kerry Place.† In 1983, the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Quality Engineering, responding to a report of a nearby resident, tested soil samples from both properties and discovered extremely high levels of polychlorinated biphenyls (â€Å"PCBs†) on the Grant Gear site and on Kerry Place where it bordered Grant Gear. EPA then investigated the site. Finding the same high levels of PCBs, it authorized an immediate clean-up of the contaminated areas. Between June 25 and August 1, 1983, EPA removed 518 tons of contaminated soil from the two properties. It then notified the Reardons that it had removed all soil with concentrations of PCBs known to be above the safe limit, but informed them that additional areas of contamination might exist, in whi ch case EPA might undertake additional clean-up work. In 1984, the Reardons subdivided Kerry Place into a number of parcels; they sold five of those parcels and retained ownership of the others. In October 1985, EPA notified the Reardons that, as current owners of Kerry Place, they might be liable under  §Ã‚ § 106  and 107 of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (â€Å"CERCLA†), 42 U.S.C.  §Ã‚ § 9606 & 9607, along with ten other present and prior owners of the properties, for the clean-up costs. In August 1987, EPA again investigated the properties to assess the feasibility of a long-term remedy for any remaining contamination. New testing showed that soil in several areas on Kerry Place was still contaminated with PCBs. In April 1988, EPA informed the Reardons of these results. The Reardons told EPA that they intended to clean up their property themselves. EPA advised the Reardons to coordinate any offsite disposal plans with EPA and to obtain EPA’s approval of a treatment or disposal facility. In January 1989, the Reardons informed EPA that they had completed their own clean-up of Kerry Place, without having attempted coordination with or sought the approval of EPA. On March 23, 1989, EPA filed a notice of lien with the Norfolk County Registry of Deeds pursuant to  § 107(l ) of CERCLA, 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(l ), on all of the Kerry Place parcels still owned by the Reardons. The lien was for an unspecified amount, as it secured payment of â€Å"all costs and damages covered by† 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(l ) for which the Reardons were liable under  § 107(a) of CERCLA, 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(a). Five days later, EPA notified the Reardons that it had filed the notice of lien. On July 12, 1989, EPA informed the Reardons that they could settle EPA’s claims against them for $336,709, but noted that this amount did not limit the Reardons’ potential liability. On September 29, 1989, EPA selected a long-term remedy for the Kerry Place and Grant Gear sites estimated to cost $16,100,000. B. Procedural History. The Reardons filed a complaint and a motion for preliminary injunction in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts. They argued that they were entitled to have the notice of lien removed for three reasons. First, the Reardons maintained that they qualified as â€Å"innocent landowners† under  § 107(b) of CERCLA, 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(b), and therefore were not liable for any clean-up costs. Second, 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(l ) provides for a lien on only that property â€Å"subject to or affected by a removal or remedial action,† 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(l )(1)(B); the Reardons claim that since some of their Kerry Place parcels were not â€Å"subject to or affected by† the clean-up, EPA erred in filing a notice of lien covering all of those parcels. Third, they asserted that EPA’s imposition of the lien without a hearing violated the due process clause of  the fifth amendment to the United States Constitution. The district court held that  § 113(h) of CERCLA, 42 U.S.C.  § 9613(h), divested it of jurisdiction to hear the Reardons’ â€Å"innocent landowner† and â€Å"overbroad lien† claims. It found that the same section also purported to divest it of jurisdiction to hear the due process claim, but held that Congress was without power to place such a limitation on its jurisdiction. Turning to the merits of the due process claim, the *1512 district court held that the lien imposed by  § 107(l ) did not amount to a taking of a â€Å"significant property interest† protected by the due process clause. The court therefore denied the motion for a preliminary injunction and dismissed the complaint. The Reardons appealed, and a panel of this court found in their favor. The panel opinion construed  § 9613(h) so as to permit judicial review of the statutory challenges to the lien, and did not reach the due process issue. In response to EPA’s petition for rehearing, however, a majority of the court voted to grant a rehearing en banc. Although the court en banc finds for the plaintiffs, as did the panel, we do so on constitutional rather than statutory grounds. II. JURISDICTION [1] We turn first to the question of jurisdiction. The district court, as we have noted, held that 42 U.S.C.  § 9613(h) purported to divest it of jurisdiction over all three of the Reardons’ claims. We agree that  § 9613(h) bars review of the â€Å"innocent landowner† and â€Å"overbroad lien† claims, prior to the commencement of an enforcement or recovery action, but we conclude that this section does not bar review of the due process claim. Section 9613(h), entitled â€Å"Timing of review,† explicitly limits the jurisdiction of the federal courts to hear certain cases arising under CERCLA. The section states, in part: No federal court shall have jurisdiction under Federal law †¦ to review any challenges to removal or remedial action selected under section 9604 of this title, or to review any order issued under section 9606(a) of this title, in any action except one of the following: [listing 5 enumerated types of actions] 42 U.S.C.  § 9613(h). The five exceptions to the jurisdictional bar are all actions filed by the government or by a private citizen seeking to enforce or recover costs for the enforcement of CERCLA; for this reason, the district court described  § 9613(h) as barring â€Å"judicial review of EPA actions prior to the time that the EPA or a third  party undertakes a legal action to enforce an order or to seek recovery of costs for the cleanup of a hazardous waste site.† Reardon v. United States, 731 F.Supp. at 564 n. 8. As a convenient shorthand, we will say that  § 9613(h) bars â€Å"pre-enforcement review† of certain claims. The district court framed the question of jurisdiction as whether the filing of a lien constituted a â€Å"removal or remedial action selected under section 9604 of this title.† As the district court noted, the terms â€Å"removal† and â€Å"remedial action† are defined terms under the CERCLA statute. 42 U.S.C.  §Ã‚ § 9601(23), (24). Another C ERCLA provision says that these terms â€Å"include enforcement activities related thereto.† 42 U.S.C.  § 9601(25) (emphasis added). The court found that placing a lien on property from which hazardous substances had been removed was a type of enforcement activity. It therefore concluded that any challenge the Reardons could make, whether statutory or constitutional, was a â€Å"challenge[ ] to [a] removal or remedial action† over which Congress intended it not to have jurisdiction unless and until EPA brought an enforcement action. Reardon v. United States, 731 F.Supp. at 569. A. Jurisdiction over the â€Å"innocent landowner† and â€Å"overbroad lien† claims. We agree with the district court that filing a lien notice is a type of â€Å"enforcement activity† related to a removal or remedial action. And we agree that  § 9613(h) bars the federal courts from hearing pre-enforcement challenges to the merits of any particular lien–challenges, for example, to the liability which a lien secures, or to the conformity of that lien to the CERCLA lien provisions. Several considerations l ead to these conclusions. First, we think that the language of the statute, read for its ordinary meaning, supports such an interpretation. Central to the entire CERCLA scheme is a provision that makes certain parties liable for the cost of removal and remedial actions. See 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(a). When the government files a lien on property to secure payment of that liability, it can reasonably be described as seeking to enforce the liability *1513 provision. Thus, the activity of filing liens is, in ordinary language, an â€Å"enforcement activity.† Second, we believe that allowing challenges to the merits of particular liens would defeat some of the purposes of barring pre-enforcement review under  § 9613(h). Congress was no doubt concerned, first and foremost, that clean-up of substances that endanger public health would be delayed if EPA were forced to litigate each detail of its removal  and remedial plans before implementing them. Thus, the Senate Judiciary Committee Report stated that  § 9613(h) barred pre-enforcement review because such review would be a significant obstacle to the implementation of response actions and the use of administrative orders. Pre-enforcement review would lead to considerable delay in providing cleanups, would increase response costs, and would discourage settlement and voluntary cleanups. S.Rep. No. 11, 99th Cong., 1st Sess. 58 (1985). As long as the remedy upon review of a lien was limited to the invalidation or modification of the lien, of course, such review would not directly delay clean-up of hazardous substances. However, we do not believe that avoiding delay was the only purpose of postponing review. As the Fifth Circuit stated in a similar case: Although review in the case at hand would not delay actual cleanup of hazardous wastes, it would force the EPA–against the wishes of Congress–to engage in â€Å"piecemeal† litigation and use its resources to protect its rights to recover from any [potentially responsible party] filing such a[n] action. . . . . . Moreover, the crazy-quilt litigation that could result from allowing [potentially responsible parties] to file declaratory judgment actions prior to the initiation of government cost recovery actions could force the EPA to confront inconsistent results. Voluntary Purchasing Groups, Inc. v. Reilly, 889 F.2d 1380, 1390 (5th Cir.1989). The same practical considerations weigh against allowing pre-enforcement review in this case. And we add to these reasons one more: information needed to decide legal challenges to liens may not be available at the time such challenges are made. To decide, for example, the Reardons’ claim that they are innocent landowners, a court must determine whether the contamination pre-dated their ownership; whether they had any knowledge or reason to know of the contamination; whether they had exercised due care with respect to the hazardous substances; and whether they took precautions to prevent releases by foreseeable acts of third parties. See 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(a), (b)(3), EPA Supplemental Brief, at 16-17 (stressing complexity of resolving innocent landowner claim). Notices of liens are likely to be filed early in the history of a response action–shortly after EPA has begun to spend money on waste removal and the  landowner has been notified of potential responsibility. See 42 U.S.C.  § 9607(l ) (providing for creation and filing of liens). At that point, EPA is likely not yet to know the full extent of the contamination, let alone when that contamination occurred, or whether it is likely that the owner exercised due care or took reasonable precautions. One purpose of  § 9613(h), we believe, is to delay review until enough is known to decide these issues. Third, legislative history supports the view that  § 9613(h) is intended to bar challenges to liability, such as the Reardons seek to make by attacking the lien filing, as well as challenges to the remedy EPA has chosen. During floor debate on this section, Senator Thurmond, Chairman of the Judiciary Committee, which drafted the section, explained: Citizens, including potentially responsible parties, cannot seek review of the response action or their potential liability for a response action –other than in a suit for contribution–unless the suit falls within one of the categories in this section†¦. 132 Cong.Rec. S14929 (daily ed. Oct. 3, 1986) (emphasis added). Senator Stafford, *1514 Chairman of the Conference Committee, stated: â€Å"When the essence of a lawsuit involves the contesting [of] the liability of the plaintiff for cleanup costs, the courts are to apply the provisions of section 113(h), delaying such challenges until the Government has filed a suit.† 132 Cong.Rec. S14898 (daily ed. Oct. 3, 1986) (emphasis added). It is certainly possible that Congress inadvertently rather than purposefully included lien challenges in the judicial review bar. Congress amended the scope of â€Å"removal† and â€Å"remedial† actions to include â€Å"enforcement activities related thereto† primarily to ensure that EPA could â€Å"recover costs for enforcement actions taken against responsible parties.† H.R.Rep. No. 253(I), 99th Cong., 2d Sess. 66-67, reprinted in 1986 U.S.Code Cong. & Admin.News 2835, 2848-49; see H.R.Conf.Rep. No. 962, 99th Cong., 2d Sess. 185, reprinted in 1986 U.S.Code Cong. & Admin.News 3276, 3278 (â€Å"This amendment clarifies and confirms that [enforcement activity] costs are recoverable from responsible parties.†). Perhaps Congress did not realize that other provisions referring to removal and remedial actions–such as the judicial review bar–would also be affected. But even if this were so, we do not see how our conclusion is altered. First, as outlined above, reading the statute to bar review of pre- enforcement challenges to liens is consistent with the language and the purpose of the judicial bar. Second, and more importantly,  Congress amended a definitional section, thus changing the meaning of â€Å"removal† and â€Å"remedial† wherever they appear in CERCLA. We cannot give the definition inconsistent readings within the statute. As the above-quoted legislative history makes clear, the 1986 amendment was certainly intended to allow the government to collect attorney’s fees in cost recovery actions. See United States v. Ottati & Goss, 694 F.Supp. 977, 997 (D.N.H.1988) (allowing attorney’s fees to United States under  § 9607(a)(4)(A)), aff’d in part, vacated in part, 900 F.2d 429 (1st Cir.1990). If liens to ensure the government’s complete recovery of its remedial costs are not â€Å"enforcement activities† related to the removal or remedial action–the view suggested by the dissent–then we do not see how a suit to recover the government’s clean up costs is an â€Å"enforcement activit[y]† either. And if â€Å"enforcement activities† in  § 9601(25) is interpreted to exclude the expenses of cost recovery actions, this would have the effect of denying the government significant amounts of attorney’s fees– which was certainly not the intent of Congress. We therefore conclude, as did the district court, that  § 9613(h) precludes judicial review of the imposition of a lien until EPA commences an enforcement action. [2] B. Jurisdiction over the due process claim. Unlike the district court, however, we do not believe that  § 9613(h) precludes federal court jurisdiction over the Reardons’ due process claim. First, such a challenge does not fit into the literal language of  § 9613(h). That section refers to â€Å"challenges to removal or remedial action selected under section 9604 of this title.† Under our reading, it divests federal courts of jurisdiction over challenges to EPA’s administration of the statute–claims that EPA did not â€Å"select[ ] † the proper â€Å"removal or remedial action,† in light of the standards and constraints established by the CERCLA statutes. The Reardons’ due process claim is not a challenge to the way in which EPA is administering the statute; it does not concern the merits of any particular removal or remedial action. Rather, it is a challenge to the CERCLA statute itself–to a statutory scheme under which the government is authorized to file lien notices without any hearing on the validity of the lien. Second, we read  § 9613(h) in light of the Supreme Court’s oft-repeated pronouncement that â€Å"where Congress intends to preclude judicial review of constitutional  claims its intent to do so must be clear.† Webster v. Doe, 486 U.S. 592, 603, 108 S.Ct. 2047, 2053-54, 100 L.Ed.2d 632 (1988); see Weinberger v. Salfi, 422 U.S. 749, 95 S.Ct. 2457, 45 L.Ed.2d 522 (1975); *1515 Johnson v. Robison, 415 U.S. 361, 94 S.Ct. 1160, 39 L.Ed.2d 389 (1974). [FN1] We do not believe that the statute expresses a clear congressional intent to preclude the type of constitutional claim the Reardons are making–a challenge to several statutory provisions which form part of CERCLA. However, it is important to make clear that we are not holding that all constitutional challenges involving CERCLA fall outside the scope of  § 9613(h). A constitutional challenge to EPA administration of the statute may be subject to  § 9613(h)’s strictures. Such a claim may well be a â€Å"challenge[ ] to removal or remedial action selected under section 9604 of this title,† and may thus fall within  § 9613(h)’s bar. We find only that a constitutional challenge to the CERCLA statute is not covered by  § 9613(h). FN1. Of course,  § 9613(h) is styled as a provision that merely delays review, rather than precludes it–indeed, it is titled â€Å"Timing of review.† However, the only available review of the lien notice is in an enforcement action brought by EPA; and the judgment in that enforcement action will render moot the Reardons’ due-process-based request for injunctive relief against the filing of the lien, since it will decide whether or not the Reardons are liable under CERCLA. Hence, the effect of  § 9613(h) is to preclude review altogether. Third, extending jurisdiction to the Reardons’ due process claim does not necessarily run counter to the purposes underlying  § 9613(h). For example, resolution of the due process issue does not require any information that is not likely to be available until clean-up of a site is finished. Because it is a purely legal issue, its resolution in a pre-enforcement proceeding does not have the potential to force EPA to confront inconsistent results (as would a finding, for example, that a particular spill was caused by an act of God). Of course, if we decide that filing a notice of a CERCLA lien without any pre- enforcement review does violate due process, EPA’s collection efforts will no doubt be hampered. However, we do not lightly assume that Congress intended to ease EPA’s path even at the expense of  violating the Constitution. Fourth, although the two courts that have considered this issue have reached a different conclusion, see Barmet Aluminum Corp. v. Re illy, 927 F.2d 289, 293 (6th Cir.1991); South Macomb Disposal Authority v. U.S.E.P.A., 681 F.Supp. 1244, 1249-51 (E.D.Mich.1988), we are unpersuaded by the reasoning of those cases. Our disagreement commences with the phrasing of the issue to be decided. Both courts frame the question as whether  § 9613(h) â€Å"prohibits constitutional as well as statutory challenges until the time pr[e]scribed by the statute.† South Macomb, 681 F.Supp. at 1249-50; see Barmet, 927 F.2d at 292. We think that this question fails to make the distinction we have noted above, see pp. 1514-1515, supra, between two types of constitutional challenges–challenges to EPA’s administration of CERCLA, and challenges to CERCLA itself. Once we recognize this distinction, the reasoning of these two courts becomes less convincing. First, says the South Macomb court, Reading the language of  § 9613(h) for its everyday meaning supports the notion that this subsection prohibits constitutional as well as statutory challenges until the time pr[e]scribed by the statute. The provision explicitly states that federal courts shall not have jurisdiction to review â€Å"any challenge† except for those enumerated. South Macomb, 681 F.Supp. at 1249- 50. But, the statute does not bar â€Å"any challenge,† without qualification; rather, it delays federal court review of â€Å"any challenges to removal or remedial action selected under section 9604 of this title.† 42 U.S.C.  § 9613(h). Because a due process challenge to the CERCLA lien provisions is not, we believe, a challenge to â€Å"removal or remedial action selected under section 9604 of this title,† we do not find that the â€Å"everyday meaning† of  § 9613(h) divests the federal courts of jurisdiction to hear such a challenge. Both the Barmet and South Macomb courts contend that legislative history–House and Senate Reports, and House Judiciary Committee Hearings– suggests that Congress intended  § 9613(h) to bar all pre-enforcement challenges, including all *1516 constitutional challenges. Upon examination, we find these materials unconvincing as well. The Senate Report states, in part: As several courts have noted, the scheme and purposes of CERCLA would be disrupted by affording review of orders or response actions prior to commencement of a government enforcement or cost recovery action. See, e.g., Lone Pine Steering Committee v. EPA, [600 F.Supp. 1487 (D.N.J.1985) ]. These cases  correctly interpret CERCLA with regard to the unavailability of pre-enforcement review. This amendment [ § 9613(h) ] is to expressly recognize that pre-enforcement review would be a significant obstacle to the implementation of response actions and the use of administrative orders. Pre- enforcement review would lead to considerable delay in providing cleanups, would increase response costs, and would discourage settlements and voluntary cleanups. S.Rep. No. 11, 99th Cong., 1st Sess. 58 (1985). We see nothing in this discussion which would indicate an intent to divest federal courts of jurisdiction to consider a claim that the provisions of CERCLA itself authorize deprivations of property without due process of law. On the contrary, the reference to â€Å"review of orders or response actions† suggests that the writers of the Senate Report focused their concern on the problems that would arise if courts reviewed the merits of particular EPA actions. Both Barmet and South Macomb attach great weight to the Senate Report’s citation â€Å"with approval† of Lone Pine, a case decided before  § 9613(h) was enacted, which they say held that CERCLA did not allow pre- enforcement review even of constitutional challenges. We think there are good reasons to discount this citation. For one thing, the 13-page opinion in Lone Pine contains no discussion of the question whether constitutional challenges to the statute as well as challenges to administrative action are barred; one can only infer that the Lone Pine court held this view from the facts that (1) the plaintiff’s complaint had one constitutional count alongside six statutory counts, and (2) the court dismissed the entire complaint. In fact, Lone Pine cites Aminoil, Inc. v. EPA, 599 F.Supp. 69, 72 (C.D.Cal.1984), the leading case holding that CERCLA did not bar jurisdiction to review constitutional challenges to the statute; and it does so, not to indicate any disagreement with that holding, but simply to agree with its holding that CERCLA does bar pre-enforcement review of administrative orders. See Lone Pine, 600 F.Supp. at 1497. For another thing, the Senate Report does not cite Lone Pine for the proposition that federal courts have no jurisdiction to hear constitutional challenges; rather, it cites it solely as an example of a group of cases, sub silentio holding that review â€Å"of orders or response actions† would disrupt the purposes of CERCLA. We do not see why this should indicate agreement with Lone Pine’s purported holding regarding constitutional challenges,  particularly since cases such as Aminoil would seem to fit just as easily into the group of cases described in the Report. We do not find the House Report any more convincing. The pertinent passage in that Report, according to Barmet and South Macomb, is a statement that â€Å"there is no right of judicial review of the Administrator’s selection and implementation of response actions until after the response action[s] have been completed†¦.† H.R.Rep. No. 253(I), 99th Cong., 2d Sess. 81, reprinted in 1986 U.S.Code Cong. & Admin.News 2835, 2863. See Barmet, 927 F.2d at 293 (quoting this passage); South Macomb, 681 F.Supp. at 1250 (same). This statement says nothing about judicial review of the CERCLA statute itself. South Macomb also cites testimony of EPA and Justice Department officials during hearings on the bill that contained  § 9613(h). In response to a query from Representative Glickman as to whether EPA and the Justice Department â€Å"might accept some form of accelerated [pre-enforcement] review,† Mr. Habicht, the Assistant Attorney General for Land and Natural Resources, replied: Mr. Chairman, briefly, this issue has been litigated under the 1980 statute *1517 quite extensively, and there have been a number of decisions over the last several months that address the fundamental questions of the constitutionality of the procedures set forth in that law. Virtually across the board now the courts are finding that the scheme is constitutional as currently constituted. Superfund Reauthorization: Judicial and Legal Issues, Hearings before the Subcomm. on Admin. Law and Governmental Relations, H. of Rep. Judiciary Comm., 99th Cong., 1st Sess. at 226 (July 17, 1985); see South Macomb, 681 F.Supp. at 1250 (quoting this passage). The South Macomb court comments: â€Å"Our reading of this exchange is that the EPA and the Department of Justice took the position that because the courts had already upheld the constitutionality of CERCLA, constitutional challenges could also await EPA enforcement actions.† Id. We do not find this passage quite so clear. It would appear to be an expression of hope by EPA and the Department of Justice rather than a statement of congressional intent, particularly in light of the fact that Congress passed a provision,  § 9613(h), that by its language does not bar constitutional challenges to the CERCLA statute. Finally, the Supreme Court recently examined a statute with a judicial review provision not unlike the CERCLA section analyzed here. At issue in McNary v. Haitian Refugee Center, Inc., 498 U.S. 479, 111 S.Ct. 888, 112  L.Ed.2d 1005 (1991), was a provision of the Immigration and Nationality Act barring judicial review of a denial of â€Å"Special Agriculture Worker† (â€Å"SAW†) status except in the context of a deportation order. The statute states: â€Å"There shall be no administrative or judicial review of a determination respecting an application for adjustment of status under this section except in accordance with this subsection.† 8 U.S.C.  § 1160(e) (as amended by the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986). The Court held that this bar did not preclude review of â€Å"general collateral challenges to unconstitutional practices and policies used by the agency in processing applications.† McNary, 111 S.Ct. at 896. Rather, it only barred review of individual denials of SAW status. Id. The statute in McNary resembles the CERCLA provision at issue here in two respects. First, as here, judicial review of an administrative event is withheld until the agency instigates a second, independent proceeding. More significantly, the immigration statute is phrased so as to bar review of the agency’s determination of SAW status in an individual action–an event comparable to EPA’s selection of a removal or remedial action, which is the focus of the CERCLA bar. Neither statute mentions the availability of review of a constitutional challenge to the statute itself (as here) or to the agency’s execution of the statute (as in McNary ). Insofar as the Immigration and Nationality Act compares to CERCLA, we think that the holding in McNary supports our conclusion here. See also Johnson v. Robinson, 415 U.S. 361, 367, 94 S.Ct. 1160, 1165-66, 39 L.Ed.2d 389 (1974) (holding that similar jurisdictional bar precluded review only of administration of statute, not of challenge to statute itself); cf. Weinberger v. Salfi, 422 U.S. 749, 762, 95 S.Ct. 2457, 2465, 45 L.Ed.2d 522 (1975) (holding that more expansive language barred all challenges related to statute). Thus, we conclude that we have jurisdiction to consider the Reardons’ due process claim: that the CERCLA statutory scheme under which liens may be imposed on property without opportunity for a hearing violates the fifth amendment due process clause. III. THE DUE PROCESS CLAIM [4] The Supreme Court has established a two-part analysis of due process challenges to statutes which, like this one, involve property rather than liberty interests. One must first ask whether the statute authorizes the taking of a â€Å"significant property interest† protected by the fifth  amendment. E.g., Fuentes v. Shevin, 407 U.S. 67, 86, 92 S.Ct. 1983, 1997, 32 L.Ed.2d 556 (1972). If there is no significant property interest involved, the inquiry is at an end. If there is, one proceeds to examine what process is due in the particular circumstances. *1518 E.g., id.; Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319, 335, 96 S.Ct. 893, 903, 47 L.Ed.2d 18 (1976). We shall address each issue in turn. A. The Deprivation. The district court, relying primarily on Spielman- Fond, Inc. v. Hanson’s, Inc., 379 F.Supp. 997 (D.Ariz.1973) (three judge panel), aff’d mem., 417 U.S. 901, 94 S.Ct. 2596, 41 L.Ed.2d 208 (1974), found that the filing of a federal lien under 42 U.S.C.  § 96 07(l ) did not amount to a deprivation of a significant property interest; thus, the court did not reach the second step of the analysis. However, a Supreme Court case decided after the district court had issued its decision (indeed, after oral argument at the en banc rehearing of this appeal) has clarified the law in this area considerably, and has precluded continued reliance on the Court’s summary affirmance in Spielman-Fond. In Connecticut v. Doehr, 501 U.S. 1, 111 S.Ct. 2105, 115 L.Ed.2d 1 (1991), a unanimous Court held that a Connecticut attachment statute violated the due process clause. The Court held that the attachment lien on plaintiff Doehr’s real property deprived him of a significant property interest within the meaning of the due process clause. The Court stated: For a property owner like Doehr, attachment ordinarily clouds title; impairs the ability to sell or otherwise alienate the property; taints any credit rating; reduces the chance of obtaining a home equity loan or additional mortgage; and can even place an existing mortgage in technical default where there is an insecurity clause. Doehr, 501 U.S. at —-, 111 S.Ct. at 2113. It concluded that â€Å"even the temporary or partial impairments to property rights that attachments, liens, and similar encumbrances entail are sufficient to merit due process protection.† Id. (emphasis added). And, in a footnote, it disposed of its summary affirmance in Spielman-Fond by noting that â€Å"[a] summary disposition does not enjoy the full precedential value of a case argued on the merits and disposed of by a written opinion.† Id. at —- n. 4, 111 S.Ct. at 2113 n. 4 (citing Edelman v. Jordan, 415 U.S. 651, 671, 94 S.Ct. 1347, 1359-60, 39 L.Ed.2d 662 (1974)). See also id. at —-, 111 S.Ct. at 2113 (Rehnquist, C.J., concurring) (Spielman-Fond should not be read to mean that the imposition of a lien is not a deprivation of a significant interest in property). Whether the response costs were incurred consistently with the national contingency plan is an issue which may be highly factual, but it is usually a matter of the amount, and not the existence, of liability. More likely to be â€Å"highly factual† is the determination whether certain of the owner’s parcels of land are â€Å"subject to or affected by† EPA’s response action. Similarly, on the issue of the landowner’s liability, EPA admits in its brief that the â€Å"concepts of due care, foreseeability, objective and subjective knowledge, some of which are unique in CERCLA to the innocent landowner defense, are extremely fact-intensive.† EPA Supplementary Brief at 16-17. Second, we must consider what procedural safeguards, if any, CERCLA provides against erroneous filing of a lien. a. The right to a judicial hearing. CERCLA provides no such safeguards. It provides for no pre-deprivation proceedings at all–not even the ex parte â€Å"probable cause† hearing judged insufficient in Doehr. See Doehr at —-, 111 S.Ct. at 2108 (describing Connecticut attachment procedure). Nor does CERCLA provide for an immediate post-deprivation hearing. [FN2] The first hearing the property owner is likely to get is at the enforcement proceeding, or cost recovery action, brought by EPA. This action may be brought several years after the notice of lien is filed; it is limited only by a rather complicated statute of  limitations, see 42 U.S.C.  § 9613(g)(2), which gives EPA three years after a removal action is completed or six years after a remedial action is commenced to bring such a suit. The running of the statute of limitations is entirely within EPA’s control. Since the government may take its own sweet time before suing, and since the removal or remedial action may itself take years to complete, the lien may be in place for a considerable time without an opportunity for a hearing. FN2. The Connecticut statute at issue in Doehr provided â€Å"expeditious† post-attachment review, see 501 U.S. at —-, 111 S.Ct. at 2115, but the Court nonetheless found the statute constitutionally deficient. Even under Doehr, though, post-attachment process is not always inadequate. Doehr notes the factors leading to the Court’s  approval, in Mitchell v. W.T. Grant Co., 416 U.S. 600, 94 S.Ct. 1895 (1974), of a sequestration statute with no pre-deprivation review: â€Å"the plaintiff had a vendor’s lien to protect, the risk of error was minimal because the likelihood of recovery involved uncomplicated matters that lent themselves to documentary proof, and plaintiff was required to put up a bond.† Doehr, 501 U.S. at —-, 111 S.Ct. at 2114. â€Å"[M]ere postponement of judicial enquiry is not a denial of due process if the opportunity given for ultimate judicial determination of liability is adequate.† *1520 Phillips v. Commissioner, 283 U.S. 589, 596, 51 S.Ct. 608, 611, 75 L.Ed. 1289 (1931). But the CERCLA statute of limitations on liens throws the â€Å"ultimate judicial determination† so far into the future as to render it inadequate. Indeed, in this respect the CERCLA scheme resembles the replevin statutes in Fuentes v. Shevin, where the Court held that the debtor may not be â€Å"left in limbo to await a hearing that might or might not ‘eventually’ occur.† Mitchell v. W.T. Grant Co., 416 U.S. at 618, 94 S.Ct. at 1905 (discussing Fuentes v. Shevin ). b. Posting of a Bond. The Court has recognized that requiring the filing party to post a bond may provide the property owner important protection against wrongful filing; in Doehr, four members of the Court suggested that due process always requires a plaintiff’s bond in the context of an attachment. See Doehr, 501 U.S. at  Ã¢â‚¬â€-, 111 S.Ct. at 2116 (plurality). CERCLA does not require EPA to post a bond when filing the notice of federal lien. c. Action for damages. In Doehr, the State of Connecticut argued that the availability of a double damages remedy for suits that are commenced without probable cause was an important protection against misuse of the attachment provisions; however, four members of the Court did not find the availability of such a suit to be an adequate procedural safeguard. Four members of the court explained in detail why an action for damages would never prove adequate: The necessity for at least a prompt postattachment hearing is self-evident because the right to be compensated at the end of the case, if the plaintiff loses, for all provable injuries caused by the attachment is inadequate to redress the harm inflicted, harm that could have been avoided had an early hearing been held. An individual with an immediate need or opportunity to sell a property can neither do so, nor otherwise satisfy that need or recreate the opportunity. The same applies to a parent in need of a home equity loan for a child’s education, an entrepreneur seeking to start a business on the strength of an otherwise strong credit rating, or simply a homeowner who might face the disruption of having a mortgage placed in technical default. Doehr, 501 U.S. at —-, 111 S.Ct. at 2118 (plurality).